At this point, we're past the point of the whole "just looking good when losing to Shayna is enough" stage. We've gotten two years of that already. She should be putting some people over, by putting them over. Also you want to make a new star, let them WIN a match against a big opponent.
Also I'm not fond of the idea of sacrificing the division for the sake of a story that otherwise has nothing to do with them. They did it last year with the SD division, and it was crap there as well.