The Rectangle: Jean/Scott/Emma/Logan Discussion

[TheCape]

LMAO XD

I wasn’t even a Yen fan ... Triss>

Eh Triss was kind of a dick too, honestly. Geralt need to take the third option IMO lol.

[Abbz_A]

Eh Triss was kind of a dick too, honestly. Geralt need to take the third option IMO lol.

Hahah true .... but I have my shallow reasons on to why I prefer Triss haha

[TheCape]

Hahah true .... but I have my shallow reasons on to why I prefer Triss haha

Understandable, i feel the same way abou Yen for a while lol.

[Abbz_A]

Understandable, i feel the same way abou Yen for a while lol.

Have you read the books?

[PsychoEFrost]

I know, i keep telling myself that i should ignore it, but just went i go out, something pulls me again.

"Some people cannot be reached, that's how you get what happened last week. I don't like it anymore than you do."

-Cool Hand Luke (1967)

[TheCape]

Have you read the books?

Sadly, no. I know that there is a lot of lore that i had read. And for what i understand both Geralt and Yen are portrayed very differently in the books but i couldn't discuss then, i only know some of snipetss from the internet.

[Abbz_A]

Sadly, no. I know that there is a lot of lore that i had read. And for what i understand both Geralt and Yen are portrayed very differently in the books but i couldn't discuss then, i only know some of snipetss from the internet.

Me too, actually.

I wanna read the books tho ... can’t rely on the Netflix adaptation haha

[TheCape]

"Some people cannot be reached, that's how you get what happened last week. I don't like it anymore than you do."

-Cool Hand Luke (1967)

I mean, i just show visual evidence that Madelyne/Scott wasn't a great relationship, while admitting that he is to blame at the end of the day. Somehow that means that Scott's characther is toxic?. That's just weird lol.

[Conn Seanery]

Folks, keep it about the comics. If someone is bothering you either report them or ignore them. You don't get to openly discuss, condescend, dismiss, mock, or trash them (unless you're fully expecting to be following them out the door).

[spirit2011]

OP telepath and she didn't know where her man was? Are you kidding me with this? She could find Scott in seconds if she wanted to but was not there for Scott that is just the excused you are giving. So please stop, for me she is a promiscuous person. Just like for you she is little saint.

We where also ask to let thos be and move on find something else.

i'm not giving any excuse. She was talking about how much she loved Scott, so that is a big no for you tring to making Jean into a cheater

Jean promiscuous LOL

[spirit2011]

OP telepath and she didn't know where her man was? Are you kidding me with this? She could find Scott in seconds if she wanted to but was not there for Scott that is just the excused you are giving. So please stop, for me she is a promiscuous person. Just like for you she is little saint.

We where also ask to let thos be and move on find something else.

i'm not giving any excuse. She was talking about how much she loved Scott, so that is a big no for you tring to making Jean into a cheater

Jean promiscuous LOL

OP telepath and she didn't know where her man was? Are you kidding me with this? She could find Scott in seconds if she wanted to but was not there for Scott that is just the excused you are giving. So please stop, for me she is a promiscuous person. Just like for you she is little saint.

We where also ask to let thos be and move on find something else.

i'm not giving any excuse. She was talking about how much she loved Scott, so that is a big no for you tring to making Jean into a cheater

Jean promiscuous LOL

completely agree, all 3 are guilty. who has greater culpability? for me is:
1.Emma: she took advantage of the emotional state of Scott to seduce him.
2.Jean: oh Jean? Yes, she was not mentally unstable, she was having a bad time because of Phoenix and how her marriage felt but even so she never wanted to read Scott's mind even though he asked her, since the beginning of NXM she started badly with that cover and kiss of Jean and Logan in issue 1 ... and then comes Morrison and makes her go to Logan and is she herself who decides to kiss him, it was not Logan who started the kiss, it was her. Afterwards she was away for a long time in which she didn't see her husband, she never informed Scott of these kisses (it's sad but even Emma told Scott what happened with Namor, Jean is supposed to be better than Emma in that sense, as she was never able to do it), she never look for a way to really solve her marital problems. (And not, go to the man who despite being your friend you knows that he has been in love with you from the beginning is not at all a good idea).

Emma told that and Scott choked the hell out of her. Even if we put part of the blame on phoenix, clearly Scott took it really seriously.
But Jean didn't thought kissing Logan iwas serious, it was some accident that never happened again. I don't see any reason to tell

3. Scott: Of course, he is not the victim or the villain of this story as some like to think, it is still debatable if he saw the kiss of Jean and Logan. I would say yes, when he looked at the forest her facial expression was angry while Emma laughed, then he look for help in Emma to SAVE HER MARRIAGE not to destroy it. Emma took the situation and we already know the end, he didn't want to be with Emma after Jean's death, but Jean also changed that, maybe Scott was the one who benefited most from all this and for that reason he is usually blamed as the biggest culprit in the affair, I think he is guilty of course but of the 3 he is the least guilty, if Emma had not seduced him and if Jean had acted differently things would have been completely different.

Scott never confronted Jean about Logan kiss, so I don't think he saw anything.
If scott really wanted to save the marriage he wouldn't go to the woman that already tried to make him cheat with her.
Scott is th emost guilty because he was the one married, he should have resisted the temptations. He gave in and screwed up his marriage
I mean put the blame on these crazy women won't work here

New x men issue 17

Attachment 79867

She was not Looking for Scott lol. Even logan was surprise she had gone so far there just for a talk xD.

Attachment 79868


Logan found sometging better then a woman and that is how his friendship with Scott began. Mess up friendship but one that sells now.

Reading this is even clearer that she is kissing Logan thinking aout Scott and wishing it would go back to how it was. I just got even more sad for Jean

[AHRNIHAL]

i'm not giving any excuse. She was talking about how much she loved Scott, so that is a big no for you tring to making Jean into a cheater

Jean promiscuous LOL




i'm not giving any excuse. She was talking about how much she loved Scott, so that is a big no for you tring to making Jean into a cheater

Jean promiscuous LOL


Emma told that and Scott choked the hell out of her. Even if we put part of the blame on phoenix, clearly Scott took it really seriously.
But Jean didn't thought kissing Logan iwas serious, it was some accident that never happened again. I don't see any reason to tell

Scott never confronted Jean about Logan kiss, so I don't think he saw anything.
If scott really wanted to save the marriage he wouldn't go to the woman that already tried to make him cheat with her.
Scott is th emost guilty because he was the one married, he should have resisted the temptations. He gave in and screwed up his marriage
I mean put the blame on these crazy women won't work here



Reading this is even clearer that she is kissing Logan thinking aout Scott and wishing it would go back to how it was. I just got even more sad for Jean

Lmao.
1.Scott was also wanted to get back with Jean.
2.Jean didn't think kissing wolverine was serious.Hmmmm,why does that make soooo much sense?Why do I think that you think there's no reason to tell.Hmmmmm
3.Same.If jean wanted to save his marriage she wouldn't have go to the man who tried to sleep with her.
4.Scott was also thinking of Jean the whole time.lol.
5.The most guilty is emma,then scott,then jean(because logan saved her from number 1 spot).

[spirit2011]

Lmao.
1.Scott was also wanted to get back with Jean.
2.Jean didn't think kissing wolverine was serious.Hmmmm,why does that make soooo much sense?Why do I think that you think there's no reason to tell.Hmmmmm
3.Same.If jean wanted to save his marriage she wouldn't have go to the man who tried to sleep with her.
4.Scott was also thinking of Jean the whole time.lol.
3.

1. didn't made enough work for that happen
2. She doesn't love Wolverine and wanted nothing with him. why would she tell Scott? it would oly make him more depressed.
3. Wolverine was her friend and showed complete support for the marriage. why wouldn't she trust him?
4 thinking about some Emma twisted Jean. what a great guy

[AHRNIHAL]

1. didn't made enough work for that happen
2. She doesn't love Wolverine and wanted nothing with him. why would she tell Scott? it would oly make him more depressed.
3. Wolverine was her friend and showed complete support for the marriage. why wouldn't she trust him?
4 thinking about some Emma twisted Jean. what a great guy

1.Like jean did?
2.She didn't love logan??If so why she kissed him??Did she keep going around kissing people?
3.Lol.So,that little period of time washed out the past?
4.You just said jean was thinking about Scott & kissed Logan.What a great girl.

[spirit2011]

1.Like jean did?
2.She didn't love logan??If so why she kissed him??Did she keep going around kissing people?
3.Lol.So,that little period of time washed out the past?
4.You just said jean was thinking about Scott & kissed Logan.What a great girl.

1. Jean tried to talk with him. I'm not sure if reading his mind would really help or make him even more ashamed.
2. She kissed him on a moment of weakness. Of course Jean isnt a seria kisser
3 When Jean and Scott married, Logan was commited to not screw their marriage
4. At least she stopped there. She was starved of affection