Originally Posted by
Jim Kelly
It's comics accurate. The classic Scarecrow didn't wear gloves. And Jim Aparo wasn't being paid to do a redesign. More likely, if Aparo or Joe Staton had got things wrong they would hear about it from fans, like me, who'd write in to point out they were being unfaithful to the original source material.
In fact, my quibble with the cover isn't Scarecrow, it's Batman and Catwoman who look more like the Earth-One versions and not so much like the Earth-Two characters they're supposed to be. Staton and George Freeman showed greater fidelity inside the comic.
However, when it came to B&B, I didn't quibble that much as long as Haney and Aparo were doing the work. They had special artistic license not to conform to continuity. But generally I think Jim Aparo was probably given reference art for the hundreds of characters he had to draw in these team-ups and he just did his best to follow the model sheets without inventing anything new.