Don't like the idea of Dick as a cop, at all, or are you more displeased that it would be a rinse and repeat of an old storyline once again, cause I can definately agree on the latter. Amnesia storylines in comics tend to be incredibly boring, at least for me, but at this point its like picking the lesser of two evils, whatever that is for people.
By the way, is there any word on how long this forgetful Ric storyline is gonna last? I think I saw someone mention a whole year, but I don't know where that figuire came from.