Who's your favorite Robin? (Robins?)

[Zaresh]

Technically, Dick is winning because, first, there is two of him. And second, he is Dick Grayson. No explanation needed.

Being certain someone doesn't make you "right" or "the best" though, unless we're talking about monarchy, non-elective monarchy more specifically \o/.

But everyone has their faves, and faves aren't rational (tastes rarely are).

[MajorHoy]

Technically, Dick is winning because, first, there is two of him. And second, he is Dick Grayson. No explanation needed.

And there were two entries for Dick for various reasons, including the fact that people who didn't like the kid/teen-sidekick version may have actually enjoyed his appearances as an adult Robin from when he was with the JSA.

Also see earlier posts:

Well, if you actually read the original post of this thread, at the end I had The additional information regarding later identities was to try and help clarify who we were talking about.

And while I probably could have split Jason into two entries (the pre-CoIE Dick-clone and the post-CoIE anti-Dick), since that was technically suppose to have been the same character (with a major retcon up his . . . you know) I let it be.
Golden Age Dick Grayson (of Earth-2) and Silver/Bronze Age Dick Grayson (later Nightwing and based on Earth-1) were two separate entities who did meet in a story.

Well, there really were two different versions. Besides, things would get even nuttier if I tried to split up Dick-as-Robin to include the post-Flashpoint version(s) that appeared in various stories.
To me, the main differences between Golden Age Dick and Silver Age+ Dick are that we never really saw Golden Age Robin as a teenager (he was either the Boy Wonder or an adult as far as I'm aware), and Golden Age Dick never gave up his Robin identity to become Nightwing.
As for "diluting the numbers in the poll", well, since "Dick" had the longest stretch as Robin (1940-1984 before he became Nightwing), it only seemed right to separate the two versions (and, again, there were two separate Dick Graysons pre-CoIE).

[adrikito]

Damian, Steph, Dick and Jason.

I am surprised for see DICK GRAYSON in 2nd position in the polls..

However if we add the golden age version votes he is in 1st position..

[MajorHoy]

Damian, Steph, Dick and Jason.

I am surprised for see DICK GRAYSON in 2nd position in the polls..

However if we add the golden age version votes he is in 1st position..

But, are all the votes for Dick Grayson specifically for his time as "Robin", or are a number of the votes for him based on his time as Nightwing, Grayson (Agent 37), or as Batman?

. . . Also please vote for the character based on their time as Robin, not just on the overall history of the character.

[Blunt-Man]

Tim Drake ( Robin ) , Dick Grayson ( Nightwing ) , Damien Wayne in all fairness and in that exact order id say those are the best and by far my favorite Robins

[MajorHoy]

A few more people have voted, so:

* Tim Drake (later Red Robin / 1989 +) = 46 votes (+ 3)
* Dick Grayson (Nightwing/Silver Age +) = 43 votes (+ 3)
* Damian Wayne (2006 +) = 40 votes (+ 2)
* Jason Todd (later Red Hood / 1983 +) = 21 votes (+ 1)
* Stephanie Brown (orig. Spoiler/became Robin in 2004) = 5 votes (no change)

And guess we should throw in:

Golden Age Dick Grayson (pre-CoIE Earth-2 / adult Robin) = 3 votes

[MajorHoy]

Since there's been all the activity on Timothy Hunter's "What New Identity Should Tim Drake Take?" thread, figured I'd update the vote count here:

* Tim Drake (later Red Robin / 1989 +) = 46 votes (no change)
* Dick Grayson (Nightwing/Silver Age +) = 44 votes (+1)
* Damian Wayne (2006 +) = 41 votes (+1)
* Jason Todd (later Red Hood / 1983 +) = 23 votes (+2)
* Stephanie Brown (orig. Spoiler/became Robin in 2004) = 5 votes (no change)
* Golden Age Dick Grayson (pre-CoIE Earth-2/adult Robin) = 4 votes (+1)

And there's also the separate Rank the Robins from Best to Worst thread.

[CPSparkles]

Since there's been all the activity on Timothy Hunter's "What New Identity Should Tim Drake Take?" thread, figured I'd update the vote count here:

* Tim Drake (later Red Robin / 1989 +) = 46 votes (no change)
* Dick Grayson (Nightwing/Silver Age +) = 44 votes (+1)
* Damian Wayne (2006 +) = 41 votes (+1)
* Jason Todd (later Red Hood / 1983 +) = 23 votes (+2)
* Stephanie Brown (orig. Spoiler/became Robin in 2004) = 5 votes (no change)
* Golden Age Dick Grayson (pre-CoIE Earth-2/adult Robin) = 4 votes (+1)

And there's also the separate Rank the Robins from Best to Worst thread.

You are a fire starter. These threads bring out the worst in fans can we give em a rest please.

[Mataza]

Its fine, at least the forums become more active and entertaining. Only thing i despise is that a lot of people here make claims without backing them up.
It is rather annoying.

[MajorHoy]

You are a fire starter. These threads bring out the worst in fans can we give em a rest please.

It's what people are talking about / participating in.

I'm sorry if that's not to your liking.

[shadow6743]

These kinds of threads are fine. Just be respectful and remember these are just opinions. It fine to like something that another person does not like.

[uchihafanboy]

You are a fire starter. These threads bring out the worst in fans can we give em a rest please.

He's just taking polls, if you can't handle a disagreement then go to an echo chamber.

Only thing i despise is that a lot of people here make claims without backing them up.
It is rather annoying.

The internet and real life is like that, get used to it

It's what people are talking about / participating in.

I'm sorry if that's not to your liking.

You don't have to apologize, no one should apologize for making a simple thread like this just because one person thinks people act mean in them.

I still wish I voted Jason ��

[dietrich]

Good lord! This post ^^^^ legit is tickles me.

[Shadowcat]

I went with Jason. I only have the issues of NTT and a few issues of Conway’s run with Dick as Robin, but I’ve never warmed to Tim, and I hate Damian.

[oasis1313]

These kinds of threads are fine. Just be respectful and remember these are just opinions. It fine to like something that another person does not like.

It's just a poll for us nerdy comic book fans, no big deal, just have fun.