Who Rules The School?

[Tycon]

Three generations of amazing, extraordinary students! All of them, for SOME odd reason, co-exist at the Xavier Institute for Mutant Education and Outreach:

The Morrison Era: Glob, Beak, Imp, Keratin, Basilisk, Angel, Beak, Ernst, No-Girl, Dummy, Spike, Redneck, Cephalophod, Crater, Slick, Phaser, Polymer, Longneck, Forearm, Mentat, Contact, Pako, Forearm, Choir, Stalwart, Tattoo, Radian


Academy X/New X-Men: Prodigy, Surge, Hellion, Mercury, Gentle, Loa, Armor, Dust, Elixir, Pixie, Anole, Rockslide, Bling!, Indra, Match, Blindfold, Three-In-One, Wind Dancer, Cipher, Graymalkin, X-23, Trance, Ink


JGS/NCXS Kids: Quentin Quire, Oya, Broo, Kid Gladiator, Eye-Boy, Nature Girl, Genesis, Shark Girl, Hijack, Sprite, Rico, Ziggy, Crosta, teen O5, Face, Primal, Velocidad, Transonic, Goldballs, Morph, Triage, Tempus

The poll is simple. Which generation is or has been your favorite?

I had to bring in some dead/depowered characters for some generations because Academy X has a lot of students. Also, I largely decided who should be in what particular group based on who they are largely associated with, which is why Quentin is in the JGS generation or why the Young X-Men & Generation Hope students get spread out with other generations.

[Rover]

It's a tough one! The New X-Men were the most likeable students for me. But I feel like the New Mutants should win because some of them actually graduated

[yogaflame]

Quentin Quire is a Morrison creation...

[CRaymond]

Morrison's Special Class, Glob, Dust, QQ, and Cuckoos will probably emerge as the most important students in due time.

Given the chance to clean the fields a bit:

I'd keep Prodigy, Rockslide, Mercury, Bling, Pixie and Anole to any background class roster.

[Anduinel]

No GenHope?

[NewMutant]

Quentin Quire
Pixie
Anole
Rockslide
Armor
X-23
Stepford Cuckoos

[Tycon]

No GenHope?

I felt weird having a poll of only five peeps. I put them w/ the JGS swuad but now I'm wondering if I should've had them under Academy X

Quentin Quire is a Morrison creation...

Also, I largely decided who should be in what particular group based on who they are largely associated with, which is why Quentin is in the JGS generation

[yogaflame]

Quire is associated with:







He was actually interesting under Morrison.

[Star_Jammer]

Why isn't Dust considered to be from the Morrison era?

[yogaflame]

Why isn't Dust considered to be from the Morrison era?

Also true.

[Tycon]

Quire is associated with:







He was actually interesting under Morrison.

Quentin was only there for an arc. Yes, he did have an impact, but his relationships are with the JGS kids now, and his personality from then and now are like comparing two, different characters.

Why isn't Dust considered to be from the Morrison era?

"Largely associated"

Are you telling me you think Dust is more associated with a group she's been with for a couple of issues v. a team she was in for over 40 issues?

[Strong Girl Daken]

Quire was in one arc of Morrison's run and Dust had a very minor role. Academy X established Dust's position in the X-men and built her dynamics with other characters. Likewise for Quite who was an antagonist before WatX built the status quo he has today.

[Star_Jammer]

"Largely associated"

Are you telling me you think Dust is more associated with a group she's been with for a couple of issues v. a team she was in for over 40 issues?

I associate Dust as a Morrison creation (as well as Quire), yes. Sorry?

S'why I asked you to explain your arbitrary specifications.

[CRaymond]

Quire was in one arc of Morrison's run and Dust had a very minor role.

QQ was featured in the BEST arc of Morrison's run, and probably the best villain of the run as well.

Dust was a bit shortchanged, I'll give you that.

[Captain Nash]

Academy X/New X-Men - no contest.