Top selling X-Books of October (#2 will surprise you)

[wano]

I mean, even Superman didn't make it into top 10. And his solo is only at issue #4.

Bendis was a mistake

[sunofdarkchild]

Magik not in top 100

The What Ifs in general did really poorly. As was stated, Spider-Man had 5 titles in the top 10, and What If Spider-Man placed at #85 and the Peter Parker What If was #58, and those were the best selling of the What Ifs. Magik also released on the last day of the month, while all the other What If's released weeks earlier, giving them more time to sell.

That said, Black Frost also released on the last day of the month, so that's really impressive for her.

[nandes]

Extermination at only #43 being the main X-Men event is... pretty bad, no?

[Maestroneto]

Extermination at only #43 being the main X-Men event is... pretty bad, no?

It’s a bad event with a predictable outcome with no attempt to create an exciting story to compensate for that. And Kid Cable is a joke who seemingly only exists to outrage the fanbase.

[Confuzzled]

I mean, even Superman didn't make it into top 10. And his solo is only at issue #4.

And Catwoman beat Superman.

A great month for iconic femme fatale Queens.

[spirit2011]

Magik not in top 100

oh no, that was a great what if.

at least Emma proved that ursuping x-women places for a decade, gave her enough popularity

[MarvelMaster616]

Wow. Emma Frost exceeds expectations, as only she can. That is the true mark of a worthy king.

[SpiderClops]

It’s a bad event with a predictable outcome with no attempt to create an exciting story to compensate for that. And Kid Cable is a joke who seemingly only exists to outrage the fanbase.

I wouldn't say bad, but nothing to write home about that's for sure. And it's about time-displaced O5. If you really think about it, it's pretty good that it's selling as well.

[TheCape]

Huh, i actually expected Magneto's Black issue in the second place but the rest is more or less how i imagined it.

Wonder how much ROW#2 dropped in regards to sales.

[Hizashi]

The What Ifs in general did really poorly. As was stated, Spider-Man had 5 titles in the top 10, and What If Spider-Man placed at #85 and the Peter Parker What If was #58, and those were the best selling of the What Ifs. Magik also released on the last day of the month, while all the other What If's released weeks earlier, giving them more time to sell.

That said, Black Frost also released on the last day of the month, so that's really impressive for her.

381407AF-A305-4002-AE2A-6B1542CBA721.jpg

I couldn’t resist.

[Tank]

I wonder how many variants each of those 1 shots had.

[Luckystar.]

Ouch. Mr and Mrs X out of the top 100 and it's only 4 issues in.

[wano]

Ouch. Mr and Mrs X out of the top 100 and it's only 4 issues in.

Maybe people are fans of rogue and gambit, but not the two of em together

[Maestroneto]

Ouch. Mr and Mrs X out of the top 100 and it's only 4 issues in.

I'll sleep better knowing that Guggenheim's lifelong dream was sacrificed at the altar of a book cancelled within a year.

[Confuzzled]

Maybe people are fans of rogue and gambit, but not the two of em together

I think it's a case of too late for Remy fans. A title like this would have scorched the charts in the 90's and early 00's. But instead, the fanbase had been left starving for too long.

I'll sleep better knowing that Guggenheim's lifelong dream was sacrificed at the altar of a book cancelled within a year.

Well, when put that way...