Originally Posted by
Zeeguy91
I'm sorry, but I just don't agree with that. Beta Ray Bill was still mortal, a superstrong alien mortal, but still mortal and an outsider to Asgard. So, why would Odin seemingly accept Bill without question and even in some respect bend over backwards to accommodate him but then instantly shun Jane?
In fact, the idea that Odin is just vehemently opposed to a mortal lifting Mjolnir is not just refuted by the first appearance of Beta Ray Bill, but also by Lee and Kirby themselves. For example, in Thor #159, which lays out their origin for Thor, Odin sends Thor to Midgard in the guise of Donald Blake because he believes that living among the mortals and learning to care for them will teach Thor an important lesson: humility. That doesn't seem to be the actions of someone who looks down on mortals or thinks of them as lesser.
I think, from the context of the story, its obvious what Aaron was going for with Odin. He was meant to be the stand-in for toxic masculinity and those with sexist attitudes that would be suspicious of a woman assuming any mantle that once belonged to a man. And, while that's actually a key part of the story Aaron was telling and it is in fact appropriate to refute those sexist notions and ideas, I just don't believe it lines up with Odin's classic characterization. And, yes, that includes the Simonson run, but not just the Simonson run. It probably would have been better suited for another character.