Originally Posted by
Yoda
He did say a lot of the right things in that NYCC panel with Bendis, and was very complimentary of Lois, but I'm solidly with you all on his lacking the ability to actually tell good stories, particularly with any type of romantic angle or just women in general, anymore. So yeah, I don't trust him to a good origin and definitely don't trust him to write women at all. Lana will probably be some sort of stereotypical hayseed first love, Lois likely some variation of his femme fatale character. I expect she'll go undercover as a prostitute or something at one point, and who knows what he's going to do with Lori. I expect all three will be treated to the half baked pervy stuff he passes as romantic that people like to oversell as some transcendent statement on empowerment or whatever.
I don't expect it to bomb. It's going to sell well and will be ordered well. But I'll be surprised if it is critically well received or has any lasting impact on the character or line. I don't think he's actually written anything from like 2000 onward that has appealed to me and much of his modern output are examples of some of the worst comics published in the 2000's. I mean, Holy Terror, DKII and ASBAR are three of the worst comics to come out in that decade and all three of those were his own solo writing. DKIII was praised for mainly not being as bad as DKII and it's likely a lot of that goes to Azzrello's credit. So on that alone to expect some transcendent origin for Superman seems really overly optimistic.
And I also don't believe that it's being set up as an incontinuity origin at all. For one, I think if that was going to happen it would be Bendis to do it. He's taken the whole Superman line under his direction. Everything is basically going through him as he feels he's going to redefine Superman for the modern era. Regardless of your feelings on that, the idea that he'd let Frank Miller handle Superman's origin in that context is not something I think is likely. Every Superman book is basically under his direct or indirect control and he's handpicked everyone working on the offshoots, from Supergirl, to the Lois & Jimmy books. This is the Bendis show for now.
More likely, it will be like Batman Damned. Exist as its own thing, with probably a lot of people at DC paying lip service to it's "greatness" but beyond that not having any real impact on the direction of the character.