Quote Originally Posted by Sam View Post
When your argument amounts to it works for some, but not for others, so it is what it is, that comes off as dismissive, because it essentially silences the other side as just a difference of opinion while they might have actual gripes and criticisms with the work that they want to express.
I don't get this though. Isn't that what everyone has actually done. Some have expressed their dislike for Bendis' writings while others aren't so bothered by it. Nobody is likely ever to change the other camp's opinion so what of this is so "dismissive"? Your opinion isn't being silenced from what I have read.