Originally Posted by
RAWRlrus
While there's a lot of potential with Emma as Black King, I'd rather have her back with the X-men for a couple of reasons.
A) It means IvX is finally behind us. Her as Black King is due not being trusted because of IvX, and the sooner its gone the better. There have been plenty of X-men who have done **** that is promptly forgotten once they return to the status quo, which IMO means her rejoining the X-men, not just allied with them.
B) Security. If she's part of the Hellfire Club, it's only time until someone joins the X-books who didn't pay attention or doesn't care, and she's stupidly evil again. Obviously being part of the X-men won't save her from character assassination (hello IvX, although she and Scott didn't really feel like part of the X-men during DoX/IvX), but I think it's more likely for something like that to happen again if she's part of the HFC.
C) She'd be more likely to be involved in the X-books. I was surprised that she showed up here, but she wasn't part of the last big X-event, and we don't know how often she'll pop up before or after. I know pretty much everyone who is in this thread frequently would buy a Hellfire Club book, but I don't think it could sustain it self. It likely wouldn't have "X-men" in the title, which I think is a huge selling point. It probably won't be a flag ship, and it probably wont' have a team full of big names (which is usually reserved for the flagships). Her as part of the HFC feels like it will be a continuation of this Uncanny run, everyone being surprised she's showing up for two issues, regardless of how those two issues are.