Quote Originally Posted by Havok83 View Post
But that doesnt fit for a number of reasons.

A) In her fifth life, Moira met Xavier when she was 13. He's slightly older than her. Either way, neither was 12.

B) This New X-men scene happened in current timeline. Xavier wouldnt have the memories of his life from Moira's fifth life to recall.

C) I dont beleive the 12th birthday party memory and day with Moira are connected at all. Xavier is spouting out random memories in this scene and that panel is cropped intentionally to make a connection but if you view the entire page, he is rambling on about random unconnected moments from his life
But on the final page did it not suggest that Moira opening her mind to Xavier was her sharing the memories of all of her previous lives with him, imparting knowledge of past errors in order to ensure that this time, together, they “break the rules” and get things right? If so, this potentially corresponds with this moment in NXM and means Charles would’ve been able to recall Moira’s fifth life. Of course, the implication of point A and her being 13 still stands but a connection could still be possible as long as further expansion from Hickman is on the horizon.