Hell yes!
Absolutely!
They want to return Cyclops to 90s.
Of course Emma is going to be a villain.
Who knows, even if I don't like Scemma and I prefer Jott, I don't want Emma to be a villain again, if all her hero era was exclusively for Scott, it will make the character really look bad and it's not fair to his fans, I hope the Scott's return will help her to be again a hero as she was before even if she and Scott are no longer together.
Give Emma some kids to teach and protect then she'll be fine. She could easily do her own thing with a school.
She'd probably be at odds with some of the X-Men due to past relations, but that wouldn't necessarily make her a villain. Main person she'd have to worry about is Magneto since the only thing he hates more than her rn is the HFC and she's BK...
I'd definitely be down for a HF book that pits her at odds with the Brotherhood.
The one thing Emma did that could give Scott pause was the whole "brainwash him to be better/her version" thing, but extenuating circumstances then and now might cause him to forgive that.
Do you think that Scott thought or hoped back when he was alive that all of the hate and vitriol aimed at him by his old teammates was for show? If so, having Tyke's memories should've shattered that idea considering how often Tyke saw otherwise firsthand. I wonder why we won't see any fallout from that angle...