Xavier's School vs Hogwarts School

[k von doom]

Both schools are transported to the arena. Professors, teachers and students who have taught and learned in the school can participate. Three days preparation. Phoenix and Dark Phoenix are not included. Who takes it?

1. Movie versions
2. Comic Book vs Book versions

Updated: What if we take telepathy off the table?

[The MunchKING]

Massive Mind-control for the win.

[Guy1]

Both schools are transported to the arena. Professors, teachers and students who have taught and learned in the school can participate. Three days preparation. Phoenix and Dark Phoenix are not included. Who takes it?

1. Movie versions
2. Comic Book vs Book versions

[theoneandonly]

I wonder if Harry can throw off mind control like he did with the imperious curse.

[The MunchKING]

Movie Xavier I don't know what his best feats are. Comic Xavier is WAY too good.

Not to mention "Magnets = Reality Control" Magneto.

[Guy1]

I wonder if Harry can throw off mind control like he did with the imperious curse.

Xavier shuts him down. Telepathy plays by different rules and Charles could casually shut down an entire mall worth of people.

[Beadle]

Even putting aside massive amounts of telepathy, you have Shaman Nate, Jesus Cable, Legion, Juggernaut, Kid Gladiator and MAAAAAAGGGNNNEEEEETTTTTSSSS!!! Need I say more?

Plus with Magik, Pixie and Amanda Sefton, they have a fair amount of magical oomph of their own.

[theoneandonly]

Xavier shuts him down. Telepathy plays by different rules and Charles could casually shut down an entire mall worth of people.

I guess then Occlumency is no help against the magic of Xaviers telepathy.

[Cthulhu_of_R'lyeh]

I guess then Occlumency is no help against the magic of Xaviers telepathy.

No one in Hogwarts has sufficient feats to resist Xavier's telepathy. In either the book, or movie.

[theoneandonly]

No one in Hogwarts has sufficient feats to resist Xavier's telepathy. In either the book, or movie.

yep but you can't help but wonder if he will be able to shut them down in an instance or if the apparently natural magical defense ability that the wizards and witches display when they are physically harmed(like Harry repelling vernon when he tried to strangulate him) would kick in and hold him off at least for some time.

[The Drunkard Kid]

yep but you can't help but wonder if he will be able to shut them down in an instance or if the apparently natural magical defense ability that the wizards and witches display when they are physically harmed(like Harry repelling vernon when he tried to strangulate him) would kick in and hold him off at least for some time.

I mean, even if it head some sort of resistance, Xavier and Jean (even without taking into the Phoenix Force) are pretty much Astral gods in the 616 universe, where even minor talents are significantly more psychically powerful than anything we've seen in the Potterverse, so the X-telepaths probably just instantly KO everybody on the opposing side without even noticing the Occlumancers' resistance.

[theoneandonly]

I mean, even if it head some sort of resistance, Xavier and Jean (even without taking into the Phoenix Force) are pretty much Astral gods in the 616 universe, where even minor talents are significantly more psychically powerful than anything we've seen in the Potterverse, so the X-telepaths probably just instantly KO everybody on the opposing side without even noticing the Occlumancers' resistance.

"if it head some sort of resistance"? I think you need basic grammar lessons even though I do understand what you are saying or you need to spell check before posting

[MindofShadow]

Paper versions, this is just plain mean. What did the potter universe do to you?


Movie version... yeah, still pretty mean lol. Unless there is some sort of magic prep to stop mind whammy, Storm tornadoes, mystique shennagians, QS feats, Magneto, ect....

[Beadle]

"if it head some sort of resistance"? I think you need basic grammar lessons even though I do understand what you are saying or you need to spell check before posting

Dude... dodgy ground, glass houses etc.

There is literally NO punctuation in the long, last sentence of your post.

[theoneandonly]

Dude... dodgy ground, glass houses etc.

There is literally NO punctuation in the long, last sentence of your post.

yeah I tend not to pay attention to punctuation while on the forum but then I find no one has yet to say that they have trouble understanding what I am trying to say. I called out his reply because it obsucates what he is trying to say somewhat though of course it doesn't mean that it's unintelligble. Anyway bringing it to his attention isn't going to punch holes in the rules of language or his posting history so there's no need for you to intervene on his behalf.