Uncanny X-Men #10 (spoilers/discussion)

[jalsrix]

But you know where Karma ACTUALLY is right?
There’s a very important reason she wasn’t here.

I know she's imprisoned with Dani and Magik but the real reason is that X-Writers didn't want her in Disassembled.

She could have been really useful in this fight.

[Snoop Dogg]

Anyway, cool cool cool that one of the very few X-Gays and one of the mutants with a physical mutation is responsible for eugenics laws.

"Nobody thinks."

"Not the writers. Not the editors."

"This is simply how things are."

"It's inevitable."

"And I accept it."

[JaffyJayne]

I know she's imprisoned with Dani and Magik but the real reason is that X-Writers didn't want her in Disassembled.

She could have been really useful in this fight.

I think this is just your extreme paranoia...

[Heroine Addict]

That's not Dani, I've already explained why she's Trinary.

Even one writer is confused.

She's THE writer of Prisoner X, and you know better than her (+JDW), how's that work? Somebody's confused, that's for sure.

[jalsrix]

She's THE writer of Prisoner X, and you know better than her (+JDW), how's that work? Somebody's confused, that's for sure.

LOL. Dani is imprisoned together with Magik, Wolfsbane and Karma, that's why they couldn't come.

Amerindians have two long braids of hair whereas East Indians have only one.

So who's confused here...

JDW seems to get the name of non-whites wrong.

[comeatmebro]

Vita is non-binary

[nx01a]

That's not Dani, I've already explained why she's Trinary.

Even one writer is confused.

You, a fan, can definitively say which character it is but the editor editing that story doesn't know which character they're editing?! Edit: OR the writer of the book?!

[jpmst17]

I liked this event. I don't know if i liked it better than Avengers no surrender, but i did like it. The last few pages of Scott were great. can't wait to see where things go from there.

[Kurolegacy]

You, a fan, can definitively say which character it is but the editor editing that story doesn't know which character they're editing?! Edit: OR the writer of the book?!

The x-books have editors? I thought they were a myth like Bendis’ ability to write people sounding like human beings or Maggot’s fanbase.

[Beetle]

Why didn't Jean ask Monet to help if they needed every bit of psychic power available?

[Silver Fang]

Why didn't Jean ask Monet to help if they needed every bit of psychic power available?

Because she sometimes gets demoted to a team bruiser who just knows how to punch stuff.

[Heroine Addict]

LOL. ... So who's confused here...

You are, I would say. Your evidence is only acceptable at face value, if at all, and your reasoning is just silly.

[Heroine Addict]

Why didn't Jean ask Monet to help if they needed every bit of psychic power available?

Because she sometimes gets demoted to a team bruiser who just knows how to punch stuff.

Where the hell was she in this ish, I still don't think I've found her for sure?!

[Silver Fang]

Where the hell was she in this ish, I still don't think I've found her for sure?!

She hidden next to a HUGE stomach. lol
Attachment 77017
On the left-hand side. Under Beast's arm, next to big-boy in her horrible X-Factor outfit.

[Ambaryerno]

You, a fan, can definitively say which character it is but the editor editing that story doesn't know which character they're editing?! Edit: OR the writer of the book?!

While I think jalsrix's "reason" is absurd (if not bordering on racist) I think you're giving editorial a LOT of credit considering all the gaffes they've let through of late. Considering how OOC Laura was in Uncanny, I'm not sure the writers DO realize what characters they're writing...