Uncanny X-Men #10 (spoilers/discussion)

[cranger]

Yeah. Her attempts to resolve conflicts with villains by peaceful means seem ridiculous and naive to me.

Finding herself in his mind and trying to talk to him felt spot on to me. This is not just some villain.

[PrezValentine]

Yeah. Her attempts to resolve conflicts with villains by peaceful means seem ridiculous and naive to me.

Yeah, but that's her son, dude. Or at least another version of the son she actually raised. I can't see Jean taking another path, even if Nate deserved no mercy at that point.

[Knives]

Yeah. Her attempts to resolve conflicts with villains by peaceful means seem ridiculous and naive to me.

Maybe but would say it fits the character. I do not expect Jean to be the kind that shoots first and asks questions later expect this from Logan .


I wonder if we will have any participation or point of view from other heroes like the Avengers or FF4 about the disappearance of the X-mens?

[Gamall]

Yeah, but that's her son, dude. Or at least another version of the son she actually raised. I can't see Jean taking another path, even if Nate deserved no mercy at that point.

And that's what makes her a bad leader. She puts feelings above duty.

[Rosebunse]

I didn't hate this issue.

But I do find it annoying that no one in universe is probably going to comment on this, even though they lost friends and even family.

Well, War of the Realms does have Wolverine in it, so maybe?

[Snoop Dogg]

I didn't hate this issue.

But I do find it annoying that no one in universe is probably going to comment on this, even though they lost friends and even family.

Well, War of the Realms does have Wolverine in it, so maybe?

WOTR is Phoenix Wolverine because Dauterman is drawing him with a hat.

[Filthy Mutie]

Somehow worse than Battle of the Atom. BotA was full of nonsensical storytelling and writers trying to step on each other's feet, but Disassembled (why is it called Disassembled?) felt like it was written by people who had a very deep loathing for the X-Men and just wanted to smash OMEGA LEVEL!!!! action figures around, only succeeding at smashing continuity and characterization. It felt like a relic from the Inhumans era, where writers went out of their way to prove how lame the X-Men franchise was.

It pains me to say that about 'Battle of the Atom', but it's true.

Like... it's flabbergasting how bad 'Disassembled' was. If this is the gold standard for the Jordan White era, I seriously don't know if I can muster the enthusiasm to buy another X-Men book. I've been slogging through these books for a handful of years now, waiting for that day when the X-Men books would get the support from Marvel it deserves, and this is what it all added up to?

It's honestly heartbreaking.

Do I dare hope Rosenberg's solo run begins rehabbing the books? Seems futile at this point.

[spirit2011]

And that's what makes her a bad leader. She puts feelings above duty.

Her feelings avoided x-men getting killed by Nate

[Snoop Dogg]

Be Jean's kid + commit murder = She still cares

Be Jean's kid + try to destroy the world = She still cares

Be Jean's kid + Get kidnapped and brainwashed = She doesn't care

All of these three events occured under the same writer, and this is why an otherwise interesting discussion about Jean's feelings vs. being a pragmatic leader is already ruined.

[Havok83]

So.. why Jean didn't call Emma and Quentin for help? They are much stronger than Sage, you know.

We dont know that she didnt call them

[Gamall]

Her feelings avoided x-men getting killed by Nate

It reminds me of Naruto. You know, a show for kids. Naively.
I miss mature comics.

[Dante Milton]

Is Legion alive?

Did they address whether the AoXM reality is in Nate's mind or did he create a pocket dimension?

[spirit2011]

It reminds me of Naruto. You know, a show for kids. Naively.
I miss mature comics.

If you think compassion is for kids. oh well

[Gamall]

If you think compassion is for kids. oh well

Compassion for terrorists? Yeah, it’s for kids.

[butterflykyss]

i thought the issue was cool with a lot the characters getting a moment to shine. seeing how it ended this didn't need to spread across 10 issues a lot of it was a waste.