Who would Win this Hypothetical Royal Rumble?

[Little_Mac]

also, did i forget to mention that pinfalls and subs can happen anywhere?

Ok. In that point, I could see Shawn Michaels/Edge/Flair hiding under the ring, popping out just to pin someone and sneaking back under there. It helps Edge a lot, though. I could see him making it much further in this case.

[Howard Allan]

*sigh*

And the answer to all comics and movie fights is "who ever the writers write to win".

Such a positive answer conductive to discussion for the Rumbles boards!!

If it was a shoot fight the answer is different. But as a wresling match today. The winner is whoever the bookers say will win. There is no leeway on that.

[Beadle]

If it was a shoot fight the answer is different. But as a wresling match today. The winner is whoever the bookers say will win. There is no leeway on that.

Yes, but there is a long-established precedent for Rumbles about professional wrestlers, with feats based on their in-ring achievements.

As Munch pointed out, your argument is basically analogous to stating that comic book characters only achieve what writers make them achieve.

We’ve debated wrestling threads this way for years. And years. You’re not likely to change that.

[The MunchKING]

If it was a shoot fight the answer is different. But as a wresling match today. The winner is whoever the bookers say will win. There is no leeway on that.

And the winners for all comic book fights are "who the writers want to win". There is no leeway on that. Guess you solved Rumbles, and we don't need to have any more threads ever. *rolleyes*

Guess you can go to the Comms board or where ever it is everyone will go without Rumbles anymore.