Originally Posted by
Vakanai
All Star Superman was as weird and whimsical as it gets, and that blew up as huge as comics get today. The MCU started out grounded with Iron Man, but by this point has grown just as whimsical and weird as All Star, so that tone could definitely work in a Superman film. As for Superman's humor vs Marvel quippy banter and Deadpool fourth wall breaking? Eh, you could be right or you could be wrong, humor is kind of a hard thing to pin down. Just because one form of humor is dominant at the moment in Hollywood doesn't mean the audience won't be thrilled with another sort of humor. Good comedic elements and humor is always funny no matter what is in style, people still laugh at slapstick after all despite it not being as prevalent as it once was.