Genie(Aladdin) VS Q(Star Trek)

[T51R]

Like it says on the tin.

Genie decides that how Q views and treats humans is deplorable. Q of course, disagrees.

They decide to settle it with a match in the Khazan.

Who takes this one?

[Beadle]

The sheer scale of Q’s reality manipulation is way in excess of anything Genie has demonstrated.

[Darkseid Is]

Good lord. We're talking a genie that's a 5th dimensional imp vs. well... Q which is basically a 5th dimensional imp.

[The MunchKING]

Genie never unmade the Universe or walked off the Big Bang.

[Godzilla2099]

Q wins this. His powers are limitless. Even the afterlife is a playground to him.

[Cyke]

As powerful as Q is, he has no feats whatsoever when it comes to musical improvisation at all. Sure, he can summon a mariachi band, but nothing that displays his own skills.
Enough of your silly games, Q! Now we move on to other games. This one's called Scenes from a Hat...

[Güicho]

As powerful as Q is, he has no feats whatsoever when it comes to musical improvisation at all. Sure, he can summon a mariachi band, but nothing that displays his own skills.

Yes but Q brought this about...


Which trumps all Genie's mischief making.

[Powerboy]

As powerful as Q is, he has no feats whatsoever when it comes to musical improvisation at all. Sure, he can summon a mariachi band, but nothing that displays his own skills.
Enough of your silly games, Q! Now we move on to other games. This one's called Scenes from a Hat...

Yes he does. He created a Mariachi band and played a musical instrument as part of the band.

Regardless, it's scale. They both can do almost anything but Q can do those things on a scale that the Genie cannot. Well, who knows? But that's the No-limits fallacy. We have no evidence that the Genie can do things on the scale of moving planets, time travel, teleporting galactic distances, surviving forces equivalent to a star exploding, etc.

[T51R]

As powerful as Q is, he has no feats whatsoever when it comes to musical improvisation at all.

Ironically, while Q is highly limited in that regard? DeLancie, the actor behind Q, is another story. Check out his credentials when it comes to arrangement, which takes up about 1/5 of the show...