Originally Posted by
K. Jones
S.H.A.D.E. certainly seems like the obvious one. Oh god with all the shadow-based powers on characters with "shade" in there name in the DCU, too ... phew ... The Shade ... Nightshade's evil brother ... ... Shade the Changing Man or Girl. Shadow Thief. It's so obvious. It's like scurrilously obvious. But then again so is a Shadowpact membership, or replacing Wonder Woman if Diana ever peaces out from Justice League Dark.
I dunno, something Charlton-ish, Ditko-ish. Maybe even a little Steranko-ish, could be cool for Nightshade if you play up the spy/shadow aspect. But something more horror could be cool, too. I've thought about this recently just because of the nature of the Charlton characters, avoiding redundancies in the DCU, and the slightly more conspiratorial nature of them - like, Captain Atom being a more military Superman (albeit all atomic and reality-shifting). Question being so X-Files/Muldery but also just rooted in conspiracy. Blue Beetle having a pretty broad legacy with a few different notes to it. The lack of Peter Cannon and lack of need for another character called "Thunderbolt". The ... well, just the weirdness of "where the heck do you even put Peacemaker"? Or Yellowjacket. And it's so hard to see any of them partnering up with each other, they all seem so isolated in their own weird little pockets.
I'd definitely play up her name, though. Like, she's got shadowy powers or whatever and so we seem to get an emphasis on "Night" and "Shade" but like ... I'd go way more in the "Nightshades are a variety of typically poisonous plants" route. DC has loads of poisonous assassin ladies, so the goal here would be ... how do you do a superHERO that uses poisons and assassin-like tactics to do hero stuff.