1. Damian
2. Dick
3. Jason
4. Steph
5. Tim
It REALLY pained me, putting Tim on the bottom. Before Flashpoint, he was my favorite Robin. But he's just been so....uninteresting since then. And hasn't really gotten any better. I don't dislike him, by any means, but he's just not the fun character that he used to be. The awful costume and codename that Bendis gave him isn't helping matters either.
On the upside, there was a time when Jason would have been on the bottom of this list
You're thinking of Carrie Kelly. Stephanie Brown was a short lived Robin (coming in between Tim and Damian) who went on to become Batgirl (and a damn good one at that) and is currently back to her original identity: Spoiler.
1. Dick
2. Tim
3. Damien
4. Carrie
5. Jason
6. Stephanie
1. Dick
2. Jason
3. Damian
4. Carrie
5. Steph
6. Tim
Jason
Tim
Dick
Carrie
Stephanie
Damian
Once more the Sith will rule the galaxy!