Looking at the results from the last few years, I"m betting on Uncanny X-Men Vol. 4 and Fantastic Four Vol. 4 making the Top 2 possibly followed by Amazing Spider-Man Vol. 5.
Looking at the results from the last few years, I"m betting on Uncanny X-Men Vol. 4 and Fantastic Four Vol. 4 making the Top 2 possibly followed by Amazing Spider-Man Vol. 5.
#20 X-MEN CROSSROADS
#19 (TIE) SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN by DEMATTEIS
#19 (TIE) HOUSE OF M
#18 MIRACLEMAN
#17 DAREDEVIL by NOCENTI VOLUME 1
#16 CAPTAIN AMERICA (SILVER AGE) VOL 3
#15 MOON KNIGHT
#14 X-FACTOR by DAVID (1990S)
#13 THUNDERBOLTS by BUSIEK
#12 X-FACTOR by DAVID (2006)
#11 AVENGERS by ROGER STERN
Captain America (Silver Age) Vol. 3 was ranked No. 3 on my list. That means 6 of my Top Ten have so far charted.
Untill now there are five Omnibus from my Top 10 that are in the results.
Ghost Rider by Howard Mackie.
Sensational She Hulk by John Byrne.
Spectacular Spider-Man by DeMatteis.
Daredevil by Ann Nocenti.
Thunderbolts by Kurt Busiek.
Intrigued to see how more of the Omnibus i voted for will be in the Top 10.
These are the Omnis from last years Top Ten that haven't yet charted:
#8 WOLVERINE (1988) VOL. 2
#6 FANTASTIC FOUR (1961) VOL. 4
#5 INCREDIBLE HULK (1968) BY PETER DAVID VOL. 1
#4 EXCALIBUR (1988) VOL. 1
#2 NEW MUTANTS (1982) VOL. 1
#1 UNCANNY X-MEN (1963) VOL. 4
We can definitely expect to see them in the Top Ten this year. That leaves four slots.
#10 ROMNIBUS
#9 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN by MICHELINIE AND BAGLEY
#8 THOR GOD OF THUNDER by AARON
#7 EXCALIBUR VOLUME 1
#6 DR. STRANGE (SILVER AGE) VOLUME 2
#5 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN VOLUME 5
#4 FANTASTIC FOUR SILVER AGE VOLUME 4
#3 HULK by PETER DAVID
#2 NEW MUTANTS VOLUME 1
#1 UNCANNY X-MEN VOLUME 4
I brew the beer you drink. What's your super power?
From Tiger Eyes on the MMWMB:
Here is what just missed the Top 60
OLD MAN LOGAN
WOLVERINE VOL 2
MARVEL WESTERNS
ALL NEW WOLVERINE
WHAT IF (1990s)
GHOST RIDER (1970s)
DARK HAWK
CAPTAIN MARVEL (1968)
X-MEN by MATT FRACTION
NEW MUTANTS by ZEB WELLS
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN by JMS VOL 2
FUN FACTS:
OVER 300 TITLES AND RUNS WERE SELECTED
MOST POPULAR SELECTION FEATURING A MARVEL CONTRIBUTOR : GEORGE PEREZ
I'm not a huge omnibus collector (in the sense that I only have 15-20), but I would get (my votes in bold):
Ultimates by Al Ewing
Cable and X-Force by Loeb
Spec. V1
(Spider-girl v1 was on my list last year, but I'll be fine if they keep going w/complete collections)
Daredevil by Charles Soule
Amazing Spider-man by Slott
Superior Spider-man
(Infinity Crusade is a maybe)
SSM by DeMatteis
(House of M is a maybe)
Thunderbolts
Thor by Aaron v1
I thought X-Men: The Twelve (Shattering, Twelve, Ages of Apocalypse, approximately) would get a few votes to start backfilling before Revolutions, and I continue to be disappointed that no one else votes for a Counter-X by Warren Ellis collection. Otherwise, another fun time and I look forward to seeing a bunch of the books on that list getting solicited so we can have fun again next year.
Blue text denotes sarcasm
Ok now I want ROM just based off that potential name!
Only voted for 4. Two made the list (x-men 4 and WCA 4). Uncanny avengers 2 and wonder man got no love.
“Generally, one knows me before hating me” -Quicksilver
This was my Top 10 and the positions at which they charted in bold:
1.Daredevil by Denny OÂ’Neill, Klaus Janson, David Mazzucchelli & Others (DD #192-218, #220-225, Marvel Fanfare #27, MTU #140-141, Moon Knight #13 & any other relevant Marvel Fanfare & MTU appearances)
2. Daredevil by Charles Soule - No. 44
3. Captain America (Silver Age) Vol. 3 (#149-192, Annuals) -No. 16
4. Amazing Spider-Man by Tom DeFalco (#251-285, Annuals) - No. 22
5. Daredevil (Silver Age) Vol. 2 - No. 34
6. Iron Fist (Marvel Premiere #15-25, Iron Fist #1-15, MTU #63-64 and any relevant MCP & MTU appearances)
7. Iron Man by David Michelinie Vol. 2 (#216-250, Annuals 8,9) - No. 41
8. Wolverine Vol. 2 (#11-31, Annuals, MCP appearances & other mini-series)
9. Golden Age Captain America Vol. 2 (#13-24)
10. Captain Britain & Marvel UK (Captain Britain & MI 13 #1-15, Annual #1, Revolutionary War Parts 1-8, Excalibur: Sword of Power #1-4) - No. 60
How did everyone else do?
Kinda surprised to see X-Men: The Hidden Years enter the field, while simultaneously a “Reprint years” (covering the team’s various appearances in other books when their own book was in reprints... basically the contents of Marvel Masterworks X-Men volumes 7 and 8, with a bit more thrown in) drop out of the ranks.
I’d happily buy both, and voted for both. But of the two, I would’ve guessed there’d be more fan enthusiasm for the latter.
The Final 60:
#60 CAPTAIN BRITAIN AND THE MI13
#59 INVADERS
#58 DAZZLER
#57 (TIE) PUNISHER VOLUME 2
#57 (TIE) MARVEL TEAM UP
#56 CAPTAIN AMERICA by MARK GRUENWALD
#55 X-MEN THE HIDDEN YEARS
#54 ULTIMATES by AL EWING
#53 CABLE AND X-FORCE OMNIBUS
#52 X-FORCE by CRAIG KYLE AND KYLE YOST
#51 SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN VOLUME 1
#50. SPIDER-GIRL V1
#49. SUB-MARINER (SILVER AGE) V1
#48. GWENPOOL
#47. WEST COAST AVENGERS V4
#46. BEN REILLY V2
#45 (TIE). GHOST RIDER by MACKIE
#45 (TIE). NEW WARRIORS V2
#44. DAREDEVIL by CHARLES SOULE
#43. CAPTAIN MARVEL by PETER DAVID
#42. X-TREME X-MEN
#41. IRON MAN by DAVID MICHELINIE
#40 DITKO SUSPENSE VOLUME 2
#39 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN by DAN SLOTT VOLUME 1
#38 GENERATION X by SCOTT LOBDELL
#37 SUPERIOR SPIDER-MAN
#36 ULTIMATE SPIDER-MAN by BENDIS VOLUME 2
#35 PUNISHER by GREG RUCKA
#34 DAREDEVIL (SILVER AGE) VOLUME 2
#33 NEW AVENGERS VOLUME 2
#32 INFINITY CRUSADE
#31 X-MEN LEGACY by MIKE CAREY
#30 ALPHA FLIGHT VOLUME 2
#29 AVENGERS OMNIBUS VOLUME 5
#28 BLACK PANTHER by PRIEST VOLUME 1
#27 IRON MAN SILVER AGE VOL 3
#26 (TIE) SHE-HULK by BYRNE
#26 (TIE) WOLVERINE by HAMA
#25 SILVER SURFER OMNIBUS by ENGLEHART
#24 DEFENDERS
#23 MICRONAUTS
#22 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN by DEFALCO VOL 1
#21 INCREDIBLE HULK SILVER AGE VOLUME 2
#20 X-MEN CROSSROADS
#19 (TIE) SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN by DEMATTEIS
#19 (TIE) HOUSE OF M
#18 MIRACLEMAN
#17 DAREDEVIL by NOCENTI VOLUME 1
#16 CAPTAIN AMERICA (SILVER AGE) VOL 3
#15 MOON KNIGHT
#14 X-FACTOR by DAVID (1990S)
#13 THUNDERBOLTS by BUSIEK
#12 X-FACTOR by DAVID (2006)
#11 AVENGERS by ROGER STERN
#10 ROMNIBUS
#9 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN by MICHELINIE AND BAGLEY
#8 THOR GOD OF THUNDER by AARON
#7 EXCALIBUR VOLUME 1
#6 DR. STRANGE (SILVER AGE) VOLUME 2
#5 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN VOLUME 5
#4 FANTASTIC FOUR SILVER AGE VOLUME 4
#3 HULK by PETER DAVID
#2 NEW MUTANTS VOLUME 1
#1 UNCANNY X-MEN VOLUME 4
My List:
1. Moon Knight Vol 1 (Moench) 15
2. Avengers 5 29
3. Infinity Crusade 32
4. Darkhawk Just missed
5. Dr Strange SA 2 6
6. Daredevil SA 2 34
7. Avengers West Coast (Thomas) 47
8. Moon Knight (Huston)
9. Wolverine Omnibus 2 Just missed
10. Hulk (PAD) 1 3
I brew the beer you drink. What's your super power?
Now that I have revealed my list I can only speak for me, but I voted for Vol5 because it has far better content than 4 in my opinion. I am not a fan of the way the Kree/Skrull War is resolved, so it kind of kills that story for me. In volume 5 we get Celestial Madonna and Serpent Crown, so for me that is a no brainer. Now that 4 is out it cleared the way for Vol 5.
I brew the beer you drink. What's your super power?
My List:
1. UXM volume 4 (1)
2. Silver Surfer by Englehart (25)
3. Infinity Crusade (32)
4. Avengers volume 5 (29)
5. X-Force volume 4 (53)
6. Avengers by Stern (11)
7. X-Factor 90's run (14)
8.GOTG 90's run volume 2 (unlisted!)
9. Bendis GOTG volume 2 (unlisted!)
10. Pre-Annihilation Omnibus (unlisted!)
I did a count and would buy 34 out of the total list. Not bad!
Last edited by Squall Leonhart; 04-19-2019 at 12:39 PM.