Captain America (MCU) Vs Thor (MCU) - Stats equalised

[KJS]

MCU Thor is reduced to being the physical equal of MCU Captain America.

How do these fights go between the now physically-equal pair?

1) Hand-to-hand only.

2) Cap has his shield...
i) Thor has a non-enchanted vibranium version of Mjolnir.
ii) Thor has Mjolnir as it was in the movies (so he can call it etc). Physical stats still the same.

3) Cap has his shield...
i) Thor has a non-enchanted vibranium version of Stormbreaker.
ii) Thor has Stormbreaker as it was in the movies (so the Thanos-piercing kind - how does Cap's shield stack up?). Physical stats still the same.

Comment on whichever fights you wish...

[Powerboy]

Thor did great against Shield agents in the first Thor movie without his powers and this scenario really makes him stronger and more durable and faster than he was in that situation since he is on Cap's level. There's really nothing to make a decision by except maybe assuming that Thor is not used to fighting with his abilities at Cap's level or with a weapon that suddenly does not do what it normally can do. But Thor again had no problem taking out all those trained Shield agents when he was not used to being on such a reduced level. So again, really nothing to go on.

[big_adventure]

I mean, Thor shows excellent combat skills more than once, probably easily on Cap's level. He's also somewhat bigger than Cap. If you take those two things, then make them equally strong and durable and fast...

1. Thor takes the majority of fight one, H2H, but likely not 10/10.

2. i. Thor probably takes the majority, but Cap ought to get some.
ii. Thor takes 10/10

3. i. Thor again takes the majority, but Cap will get some.
ii. Thor takes 10/10

[Marvel-Studios Rep]

Cap 10/10.
Cap fought holding back Loki fairly evenly, whereas holding back Thor had issues with Loki. Means Cap is the superior skilled one against people @ or above his level. Thor is no slouch, but basically any Supersoldier skill feat can be swapped in for the Cap

[big_adventure]

Cap 10/10.
Cap fought holding back Loki fairly evenly, whereas holding back Thor had issues with Loki. Means Cap is the superior skilled one against people @ or above his level. Thor is no slouch, but basically any Supersoldier skill feat can be swapped in for the Cap

OK, think of how ridiculous what you just said sounds:

Your words:
1. Cap fought "holding back" Loki fairly evenly. How much do you think that feat matters given that Loki NEEDED to be caught for his plan to go forward?
2. Loki gave "issues" to a "holding back" Thor. How much of a feat is that for Loki? ESPECIALLY given that each time they tussle, one thing happens when Thor stops "holding back": Loki gets one-shotted.

My 10 year old son can fight evenly with me when I'm holding back. It's not an impressive feat for him, at all.

[The Arbiter]

OK, think of how ridiculous what you just said sounds:

Your words:
1. Cap fought "holding back" Loki fairly evenly. How much do you think that feat matters given that Loki NEEDED to be caught for his plan to go forward?
2. Loki gave "issues" to a "holding back" Thor. How much of a feat is that for Loki? ESPECIALLY given that each time they tussle, one thing happens when Thor stops "holding back": Loki gets one-shotted.

My 10 year old son can fight evenly with me when I'm holding back. It's not an impressive feat for him, at all.

I dunno man. Your kid is sounding like real Rumbles material. 10 year old son vs a baby mountain goat!

On topic- Steve has more feats of "Back flips! Judo! Kaaaratay!" then Thor, so he might win the h2h battle. Thor is an absolute savant with weapons though. I imagine his style and experience win him any fight involving a weapon in hand.