Rate it: Justice League by Snyder

[Korath]

I freaking love it. I'm a lover of all things cosmics, and his run is giving me that in troves. Today's issue is particularly stellar, I really like how it manages to both rewrite the history of the DC Multiverse and its most important denizens without altering whatever happened before in publication's time. That's amazing.

[LP22]

2 out of 10 one of the worst I think I miss Geoff on justice league

[Sam]

It's absolutely fantastic, particularly this current arc, which might be one of my favorite Justice League arcs ever.

[lemonpeace]

I love it, I have my criticisms but it has some really great highs and very few lows. When it's hitting it's stride, on a high I'd say a strong to high 9/10 (some 10/10 moments) and on an average about a strong 7/10.

[king81992]

It would be a lot better if Snyder stopped trying to force epicness and let it come naturally. That being said I like the story.

[Robotman]

Very low. Snyder is at his worst when he tries to throw a lot of grand concepts out there with no real direction. Did we ever find out what Lex’s doorknob was all about?

[ConnorHawke]

It's pretty poor, IMO.

He's trying to make a really complex dish but left out half the ingredients.

[Kaijudo]

Terrible. Building off of how awful Metal was, he's coming off as desperate to be a "big thinker" writer along the lines of Morrison or Moore and it's amounting to little more than cosmic thumb-twiddling. I like that he brought the Will Payton Starman back but that's probably the only real positive I can say.

What's funny is that when I saw title of the thread I thought it was going to be about ZACK Snyder's Justice League, which might be the only one I enjoy even less than this.

[Timothy Hunter]

The consensus seems to be you either love or hate Snyder's Justice League run. Similar to Tom King's Batman, Bendis's Superman and Young Justice, and to a lesser extent, Kelly Sue DeConnick's Aquaman, G Willow Wilson's Wonder Woman, and "Ric" Nightwing.

DC is publishing a lot of divisive material at this time.

[BatmanJones]

I love it.

His Batman run was okay but left me sort of cold. Same for All-Star Batman. I like Batman Who Laughs pretty well but his JL is my favorite thing he's written for DC.

[Jody Garland]

6.5/10? It's fun in a way I think Justice League should reach for- the blockbuster, widescreen style. Doesn't always land in the writing department, as to be expected from Snyder, but it's not the worst.

[ulti]

Jarro ! Best new Character !!!!!

[Bromor]

I tried it, and i dropped it for 3 reason.
1) i felt like even in the first arc he was overdoing it. It was like... too much.
2) i can't take Luthor in this one, and he was going to stick so...
3) it dosen't feel like Justice League. It feels like Countdown to Doom war/Metal 2.

[Franny6422]

I tried it, and i dropped it for 3 reason.
1) i felt like even in the first arc he was overdoing it. It was like... too much.
2) i can't take Luthor in this one, and he was going to stick so...
3) it dosen't feel like Justice League. It feels like Countdown to Doom war/Metal 2.

'Countdown to Doom' Now that has a ring to it!

[BatmanJones]

I posted above that I've loved the run so far and that's mostly true. I'd previously thought Drowned Earth was a low point and was only 'okay.' I found today's issue to be dead boring though. I usually like Tynion's writing but the latest issue felt like an exposition dump with a bunch of sci-fi mumbo jumbo in place of any actual exposition. And I'm agnostic on Manapul so the art wasn't a draw for me either. Here's hoping it gets back on track with the next one.