If they thought he lacked masculine virtue, then why did they have join in the time heist? Why didn't they see him and go, "Oh you're fat now. BYEEEEE FATTTIEE!"? Or however the kids make fun of the portly these days, I dunno.
Instead they brought him in and gave him an important mission to help save half off all life in existence. Seems like they valued him despite his beer gut. Seemed like he held his own even while fat against Thanos in the end battle. At the end of the film, all the while still being fat, he comes to a personal acceptance of his role in life (i.e. never wanted to be a leader, and moves away from leadership role) and joined a new crew/life where he is confidant and proud about.
Yeah, this is totally a fat shaming movie.
It's a fat shaming movie, I agree, but one of the key points of the movie though was that even with the massive PTSD and the obesity that came with it, Mjolnir came to him because his worthiness didn't depend on his depression. The other Avengers had him join in the time heist because they believed in him even if he didn't.
That's not to say that it justifies the fat shaming at all. The movie can have Thor display both, it's just that the weight gain is played up for humor rather than as a real consequence of depression, and that's what turns it into fat shaming. It's done poorly. Just a few minor tweaks here and there and it wouldn't be the case (Watchmen, for all its faults, didn't really play Owlman's weight gain for humor, but rather to show that his life had changed and he had aged, for example).
(on the same token, I understand while people would giggle or cheer when Thor decapitated Thanos, but that reaction kind of irks me, because I really don't think it was meant to be played for humor that came from a meme. Rather, Thor decapitated Thanos for redemption and couldn't find it after the fact, and so I really feel like Hemsworth was trying to play it as tragic vengeance, making his PTSD all the more understandable. This is a guy who wallowed in regret every single moment of every single day since Wakanda, and that was even before the 5 year jump).
Last edited by Cyke; 05-16-2019 at 03:29 PM.
This I agree with. The way he says "I went for the head" was really well delivered by Hemsworth, as you could tell that was the moment the full weight of his perceived failure hits him. Up until that point he'd really just been pissed, as Rocket points out, but he still had hope it could be undone, especially when they get a solid lead on Thanos. Once it becomes clear the stones are destroyed and all hope of reversing the snap was gone, he realises the only thing he has left is vengeance, so he does what he feels he should have done the first time hoping it will somehow redeem him. You can literally hear how hollow that victory feels as the shock hits him.
The tragic part is that it was Thor's need for vengeance that allowed Thanos time to snap his fingers in the first place. If Thor had no real emotional connection to killing Thanos, he may very well have gone straight for the head the first time. After what had been done to his people, Loki, and specifically Heimdall, he wanted Thanos to know who killed him, and he wanted to see the pain and fear in his eyes as he pushed the axe into his chest. That indulgence is what cost them. Probably even more than Quill's mistake on Titan. That was a pure red mist moment. It was still a dumb move, but Quill has form for letting his emotions drive his actions, so the way he reacted was understandable. Thor had time to stew on what Thanos had done to him, and he knew he wanted to make Thanos suffer before he died.
Currently Reading
Immortal Hulk | Avengers | Thanos | Cosmic Ghost Rider | Darth Vader: Dark Visions | Guardians of the Galaxy | Fantastic Four
Justice League | DCeased | The Batman Who Laughs | Green Lantern | Heroes in Crisis | Doomsday Clock | Last Knight on Earth
Aliens: Rescue | Invisible Kingdom
Hmmmm...Don't agree it's a fat-shaming movie. It's played for laughs at first because it's unexpected, but it's not like he's called names or portrayed in a negative light because of his body shape. It's a key part of his emotional journey.
And...Mjolnir came to him because he got his head on straight after talking to his mother. He never tried to pick it up before that.
i keep wanting to tell people "spoiler, Sherlock Holmes dies in Avengers."
I think restorative nostalgia is the number one issue with comic book fans.
A fine distinction between two types of Nostalgia:
Reflective Nostalgia allows us to savor our memories but accepts that they are in the past
Restorative Nostalgia pushes back against the here and now, keeping us stuck trying to relive our glory days.
People theorized that the mouse might have been more than it seemed. Some have said it was really Loki, for instance.
Every day is a gift, not a given right.
I assume he means the mouse is representative of Disney?