Seven soldiers of victory TPB/HC vs Omnibus

[osakafanz]

Are the TPBs/HCs volume 1 and 2 in the correct reading order?

Or...

The omnibus in the version with the correct reading order only?

[jb681131]

Are the TPBs/HCs volume 1 and 2 in the correct reading order?

Or...

The omnibus in the version with the correct reading order only?

TPB in 4 volumes order is:
vol.1
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS OF VICTORY #0
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: SHINING KNIGHT #1-2
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: THE GUARDIAN #1-2
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: ZATANNA #1-2
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: KLARION #1
vol.2
-- KLARION #2-3
-- SHINING KNIGHT #3-4
-- GUARDIAN #3-4
-- ZATANNA #3
vol.3
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: MISTER MIRACLE #1-2
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: ZATANNA #4
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: KLARION THE WITCHBOY #4
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: BULLETEER #1-2
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: FRANKENSTEIN #1
vol.4
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: FRANKENSTEIN #2-4,
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: MISTER MIRACLE #3-4
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS: BULLETEER #3-4
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS OF VICTORY #1

TPB in 2 volumes order is:
vol.1:
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS OF VICTORY #0
-- THE GUARDIAN #1-4
-- KLARION #1-3
-- ZATANNA #1-3
-- THE SHINING KNIGHT #1-3
vol.2:
-- MISTER MIRACLE #1-4
-- BULLETEER #1-4
-- ZATANNA #4
-- KLARION #4
-- FRANKENSTEIN #1-4
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS OF VICTORY #1

Omnibus order:
-- Seven Soldiers of Victory #0 (Part 1)
-- Seven Soldiers: Shining Knight #1 (Part 2)
-- Seven Soldiers: Manhattan Guardian #1 (Part 3)
-- Seven Soldiers: Zatanna #1 (Part 4)
-- Seven Soldiers: Klarion #1 (Part 5)
-- Seven Soldiers: Shining Knight #2 (Part 6)
-- Seven Soldiers: Manhattan Guardian #2 (Part 7)
-- Seven Soldiers: Zatanna #2 (Part 8)
-- Seven Soldiers: Klarion #2 (Part 9)
-- Seven Soldiers: Shining Knight #3 (Part 10)
-- Seven Soldiers: Manhattan Guardian #3 (Part 11)
-- Seven Soldiers: Klarion #3 (Part 12)
-- Seven Soldiers: Shining Knight #4 (Part 13)
-- Seven Soldiers: Zatanna #3 (Part 14)
-- Seven Soldiers: Manhattan Guardian #4 (Part 15)
-- Seven Soldiers: Klarion #4 (Part 16)
-- Seven Soldiers: Mister Miracle #1 (Part 17)
-- Seven Soldiers: Zatanna #4 (Part 18)
-- Seven Soldiers: Bulleteer #1 (Part 19)
-- Seven Soldiers: Frankenstein #1 (Part 20)
-- Seven Soldiers: Mister Miracle #2 (Part 21)
-- Seven Soldiers: Bulleteer #2 (Part 22)
-- Seven Soldiers: Frankenstein #2 (Part 23)
-- Seven Soldiers: Mister Miracle #3 (Part 24)
-- Seven Soldiers: Bulleteer #3 (Part 25)
-- Seven Soldiers: Frankenstein #3 (Part 26)
-- Seven Soldiers: Mister Miracle #4 (Part 27)
-- Seven Soldiers: Bulleteer #4 (Part 28)
-- Seven Soldiers: Frankenstein #4 (Part 29)
-- Seven Soldiers of Victory #1 (Part 30)

^- could someone confirm the orders I posted

Here (in France) we have 2 volumes (part of the Final Crisis Omnibus) in the following order:
vol.1:
-- Seven Soldiers of Victory 0
-- Seven Soldiers: Shining Knight 1-4
-- Seven Soldiers: Guardian 1-4
-- Seven Soldiers: Zatanna 1-3
-- Seven Soldiers: Klarion the Witcher Boy 1-3
vol.2:
-- Seven Soldiers of Victory #1
-- Seven Soldiers : Mister Miracle #1-4
-- Seven Soldiers : Frankenstein #1-4
-- Seven Soldiers : Bulleteer #1-4
-- Seven Soldiers : Zatanna #4
-- Seven Soldiers : Klarion the Witch Boy #4


The original publication order is:
Corresponds to the TPB in 4 volumes


I think that some stories are disconnected ans can be read in any order.
I also think that the best reading order is the publishing order.

[T.D.]

Omnibus order:
-- SEVEN SOLDIERS #0-1
-- SHINING KNIGHT #1-4
-- GUARDIAN #1-4
-- ZATANNA #1-4
-- KLARION #1-4
-- MISTER MIRACLE #1-4
-- BULLETEER #1-4
-- FRANKENSTEIN #1-4

This is incorrect. The Omnibus is arranged in correct reading order.

The table of contents is shown here (linked at 3:15):

https://youtu.be/WTYkrIApexw?t=195

[jb681131]

This is incorrect. The Omnibus is arranged in correct reading order.

The table of contents is shown here (linked at 3:15):

https://youtu.be/WTYkrIApexw?t=195

Thanks I found the correct order for the Omnibus and corrected my post.
I you know what are the correct order for the other collected editions, please do tell me.

[Brian]

Thanks I found the correct order for the Omnibus and corrected my post.
I you know what are the correct order for the other collected editions, please do tell me.

The two-volume set is in the same order as the omnibus. And I'd assume the 4-volume set is as well. I think all the collected editions are in publication order, which is considered the correct reading order.

[osakafanz]

If the order is the same for all editions...

I rather wait for the reprint of the 2x HCs then heee

[osakafanz]

This is incorrect. The Omnibus is arranged in correct reading order.

The table of contents is shown here (linked at 3:15):

https://youtu.be/WTYkrIApexw?t=195

Only the omnibus is in the correct order???