Do you think DC has gone the wrong way with their movies?

[Lexrules]

With all the success that Marvel is having with fun lighthearted comic book movies do you think DC has made a mistake by going the more serious dark route with theirs.

[Pharozonk]

Oh god Lex, you know this is gonna get ugly.

[Lexrules]

Oh god Lex, you know this is gonna get ugly.

LOL, I hope not. I'm really curious to see what people think in a civilized manner.

[FishboneX]

No, the Nolan/Snyder films, all 4, have made a ton of cash as well.

[Buried Alien]

I don't think we can answer this question until we at least see the results of DAWN OF JUSTICE. Everything from before MAN OF STEEL, regardless of quality or success, was not designed to establish a DC cinematic universe (just individual superhero movies and their sequels). MAN OF STEEL was the first brick laid down for the DCCU, but it was only a first brick.

Buried Alien (The Fastest Post Alive!)

[Lexrules]

I don't think we can answer this question until we at least see the results of DAWN OF JUSTICE. Everything from before MAN OF STEEL, regardless of quality or success, was not designed to establish a DC cinematic universe (just individual superhero movies and their sequels). MAN OF STEEL was the first brick laid down for the DCCU, but it was only a first brick.

Buried Alien (The Fastest Post Alive!)

True but it did come off a long string of serious movies and the tone will be serious in BvS.

[Buried Alien]

True but it did come off a long string of serious movies and the tone will be serious in BvS.

If you mean the tone of the upcoming movies (assuming they will be serious), I think they'll do just fine. I think the viewing public at large wants/expects it, and it's a wise strategy considering the Marvel films seem to have already cornered the lighter side of superhero movie fare.

Buried Alien (The Fastest Post Alive!)

[Sacred Knight]

With all the success that Marvel is having with fun lighthearted comic book movies do you think DC has made a mistake by going the more serious dark route with theirs.

Only time will tell. There's only one movie released in regards their newly planned movieverse, and that was a hit so the evidence thus far would suggest no. But again they're only one movie in.

On a personal level though, I think virtually every Marvel movie ever released has been overrated. They're all mediocre to me at best. So I'm fine knowing DC isn't copying them.

[rorschach51]

Only time will tell. There's only one movie released in regards their newly planned movieverse, and that was a hit so the evidence thus far would suggest no. But again they're only one movie in.

On a personal level though, I think virtually every Marvel movie ever released has been overrated. They're all mediocre to me at best. So I'm fine knowing DC isn't copying them.

Oh god, so much this! This shit doesn't get said enough, if hardly ever at all. Marvel has produced several steaming turds. The Incredible Hulk while better than Ang Lee's Hulk still wasn't very good. Both Iron Man movies after the first sucked ass (imo.) The 1st Thor was just okay with the second being slightly worse, and those are just the Marvel Studio's movies that weren't all that. If you take into account the Marvel character movies that were made by other studios the shitty list gets much longer Daredevil, X2, Hulk, Elektra, XM:TLS, Ghost Rider, Spider-Man 3, FF:ROTSS, XMO:W, GR:SOV, The Wolverine, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 all range from god what the fuck were they thinking, to fuck that sucked! But everybody thinks of all things Marvel as perfect right now, so nothing critical hardly ever gets said from comic book/comic book movie fans.

[Draegwolf]

My main issue with DC is that they're scrambling to catch up to Marvel instead of taking the time to develop their cinematic universe more carefully. DC has always had a bad habit of casting big name actors to try to cover for otherwise mediocre writing and plots of their films. It really doesn't help that over the years they've limited themselves to banking on the success of solely Batman and Superman while letting their other characters languish in cinema hell, the few times they've ventured into other characters they've either been too obscure (Jonah Hex), butchered (Catwoman, Green Lantern), or based on comics unaffiliated with the mainstream (RED, Watchmen, The Losers).

I mean look at how they're handling the Suicide Squad, can't really say I've seen anything that's impressed me and in all honestly I'm not really all that confident that the movie isn't going to suck. Between the casting and character lineup makes me think DC is just cramming as many noteworthy people in as they can in a desperate gambit to salvage what will likely be a weak plot. Mind you I reserve judgement until I actually see the movie but I'm not really expecting much. The same can be said about the everything that's going to be following. I love Jason Momoa but he's not the guy I would have gotten for Aquaman, ditto with Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman.

[The Darknight Detective]

My main issue with DC is that they're scrambling to catch up to Marvel instead of taking the time to develop their cinematic universe more carefully. DC has always had a bad habit of casting big name actors to try to cover for otherwise mediocre writing and plots of their films. It really doesn't help that over the years they've limited themselves to banking on the success of solely Batman and Superman while letting their other characters languish in cinema hell, the few times they've ventured into other characters they've either been too obscure (Jonah Hex), butchered (Catwoman, Green Lantern), or based on comics unaffiliated with the mainstream (RED, Watchmen, The Losers).

You're blaming the wrong people, though. WB calls the shots, not DC.

[Triple J]

Hmm..MOS was released in 2013. BvS in 2016. That's 3 years..so you think, 3 years wasn't enough?

I don't get the whole rushing argument..had they done this in 2014, sure. No, this is 3 years we are talking about.

My main issue with DC is that they're scrambling to catch up to Marvel instead of taking the time to develop their cinematic universe more carefully. DC has always had a bad habit of casting big name actors to try to cover for otherwise mediocre writing and plots of their films. It really doesn't help that over the years they've limited themselves to banking on the success of solely Batman and Superman while letting their other characters languish in cinema hell, the few times they've ventured into other characters they've either been too obscure (Jonah Hex), butchered (Catwoman, Green Lantern), or based on comics unaffiliated with the mainstream (RED, Watchmen, The Losers).

Not sure where you got that from..care to elaborate? DC has had their fair share of failures, but it's not like they didn't try, and deliberately got bad directors/writers.

Sure, they focused on Batman and Superman, but like you mentioned they also made a few other movies.

And it certainly doesn't apply to either of the current films (BvS or SS). BvS is written by Terrio (writer of Argo) and directed by Snyder (he's a great director, as long as he has a great script).

SS is written and directed by David Ayer (Ostrander is co-writing the movie).

I mean look at how they're handling the Suicide Squad, can't really say I've seen anything that's impressed me and in all honestly I'm not really all that confident that the movie isn't going to suck. Between the casting and character lineup makes me think DC is just cramming as many noteworthy people in as they can in a desperate gambit to salvage what will likely be a weak plot. Mind you I reserve judgement until I actually see the movie but I'm not really expecting much. The same can be said about the everything that's going to be following. I love Jason Momoa but he's not the guy I would have gotten for Aquaman, ditto with Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman.

They have done both - some noteworthy actors/actresses and some oddball choices (what would you have them choose? Anyways, that's the same thing Marvel did. No one imagined RDJ or Chris Evans as Ironman or Captain America. But, can people think of other actors portraying those roles?).

[Lightning Rider]

I kind of like it better that we're getting the shared Universe right away. In a way it makes it more believable, counter-intuitively. Instead of having to explain every single character through a brand new origin with the usual cliches, and having to repeatedly suspend our disbelief over and over as a hero gets their powers and fights & defeats a one-dimensional villain developed within less than a 2 hour time-frame, we're getting introduced to characters already-established in many ways in just 2 films, and the concept of meta-humans is becoming acknowledged. An Affleck Batman movie, a Wonder Woman movie, an Aquaman movie, and a second Superman movie starring Luthor would have been excessive and unnecessary. Those can come after. I like that Superman, DC's epicenter, is "drawing them out".

[Marvel_Is]

With all the success that Marvel is having with fun lighthearted comic book movies do you think DC has made a mistake by going the more serious dark route with theirs.

Is water wet?