Frank Castle is a Supervillain: Change my mind!!!!!!!!!

[Triniking1234]

He should stop killing people for things that are not punishable by a death sentence.

Then he will not be a villain.

I'm not sure what Punisher books Marvel's putting out these days but the Castle I knew from the OG War Journal only went after people who did things that were punishable by death.

[Michael Watkins]

I'm not sure what Punisher books Marvel's putting out these days but the Castle I knew from the OG War Journal only went after people who did things that were punishable by death.

is Goldbug chopped liver?

[Triniking1234]

He's shot liver now.

[The Negative Zone]

In no way did I say it didn't count against him. Show me were I said it? It's canon. I can't argue that it's true, but I can argue that I think it's OOC. Just like some of the things writers had Tony do during Civil War. They were OOC, but they are canon. I can't argue that they are true, but again I can argue that they are OOC. Get it now.

I wasn't specifically referring to just you to be fair, however, you guys aren't really arguing anything outside of saying it is OOC as if it doesn't count towards the question of the thread.

[phantom1592]

I'm not sure what Punisher books Marvel's putting out these days but the Castle I knew from the OG War Journal only went after people who did things that were punishable by death.

Nahhh… There were a LOT of drug dealers, pimps, pushers and armed robbers who he'd gun down that could have 'only' served time. Not to mention the hundreds of henchmen who hadn't had time to kill anyone yet. Capital crimes are pretty few and far between and Frank was never that picky. Criminals who prey on others... get shot.

[Tony Stark]

I wasn't specifically referring to just you to be fair, however, you guys aren't really arguing anything outside of saying it is OOC as if it doesn't count towards the question of the thread.

Like I said I know it counts. Frank other than the Marines has never been a joiner. That's my point. Although again it is established canon that he joined Hydra. He's been on teams before, but it was never just straight up joining. There was always a catch to it.

[Alan2099]

My favorite example of Frank "on a team" was the original marvel Knights series. He never joined but he knew the team was after him, so he'd lure them to his targets to take them out.

Punisher teamwork at it's finnest.

[K7P5V]

My favorite example of Frank "on a team" was the original marvel Knights series. He never joined but he knew the team was after him, so he'd lure them to his targets to take them out.

Punisher teamwork at it's finnest.

Agreed. Chuck Dixon certainly knew how to write these types of stories in a clever and entertaining way.

[Tony Stark]

My favorite example of Frank "on a team" was the original marvel Knights series. He never joined but he knew the team was after him, so he'd lure them to his targets to take them out.

Punisher teamwork at it's finnest.

You are so right. That was a damn good book and it showed how cunning Frank is.