Uncanny X-Men #18 spoilers and discussion

[spirit2011]

She wasnt like this circa SC. She was much better in her series. Rosenberg writes the worst Hope but thats somewhat understandable given whats happened with her recently

I kinda of like Hope being the A-hole extremist for now

[jawbreaker]

Surprise! It was Karma who had a conversation with Jono.

As far as I can remember, Karma and Jono were never on the same team before this.

Karma should have been quite close to Illyana but why is Illyana angry?

that scene is so weird, they've never met! Yet we don't get a single scene of Chamber reacting to Banshee and his current state.

[super curry max]

Was sinisters new power a call back to the xmen/spiderman mini from a decade ago with the kraven clone?

[jalsrix]

that scene is so weird, they've never met! Yet we don't get a single scene of Chamber reacting to Banshee and his current state.

Karma is portrayed as the 'angel' in this series, she gave comfort to Chamber and built a new X-building for the X-Men.

But I am angry with Rosenberg for putting her in limbo again when there are only four issues left of his run.

Whereas Hope is portrayed as the 'devil' who has no qualms about killing anybody.

[Havok83]

Karma is portrayed as the 'angel' in this series, she gave comfort to Chamber and built a new X-building for the X-Men.

But I am angry with Rosenberg for putting her in limbo again when there are only four issues left of his run.

Whereas Hope is portrayed as the 'devil' who has no qualms about killing anybody.

better limbo than dead but with 4 issues left, we cant be even sure of that yet

[Decoy]

I wonder if Cyclops would interrogate Sinister......compare notes, try to gain insight into their current plight.....ask if not Sinister, who benefits from all this......

[Glio]

Unless Scott saved Stephan's helmet, interrogating Sinister seems a terrible idea considering he is a telepath.

[Rufio]

that scene is so weird, they've never met! Yet we don't get a single scene of Chamber reacting to Banshee and his current state.

It is weird, but I think there was supposed to be a bunch of time that passed. The problem with this run is the blank time in the background. For instance, the time it takes to build a structure. Guess they had plenty of time to get to know each other, but this is why I hate off screen/panel “character development.”

[Harpsikord]

Hot take but Hope is the best thing about this series.

[Omega Alpha]

Hot take but Hope is the best thing about this series.

Rosenberg's Hope is a psychopath. Who takes out their grandfather's eye when he's trying to stop a murder and doesn't show any regrets?

[spirit2011]

Rosenberg's Hope is a psychopath. Who takes out their grandfather's eye when he's trying to stop a murder and doesn't show any regrets?

that was a accident

[phoenixzero23]

Hot take but Hope is the best thing about this series.

I agree. She is a badass

[Harpsikord]

Rosenberg's Hope is a psychopath. Who takes out their grandfather's eye when he's trying to stop a murder and doesn't show any regrets?

Sure. Let's go with that.

[Omega Alpha]

that was a accident

She still shows no remorse whatsoever, no apologies, no considerations about what her father would think of that, etc. And Scott is the one being portrayed as unreasonable.

[myownlittleusername]

She still shows no remorse whatsoever, no apologies, no considerations about what her father would think of that, etc. And Scott is the one being portrayed as unreasonable.

Considering the breakneck pace of this book and how the plot jumps from point to point with no time let it sink in, including the deaths of multiple young mutants, you really expect this part to get that much attention?