On a scale of 0 through 10 how would you rate the morality of X-Characters

[The Thunderbird]

Inspired by another thread that had discussed which X-Men fit the heroic archetype. I'm thinking that at least in X-Men there is quite a bit of nuance between hero and villain. Assuming 0 is pure sociopathic evil, 5 is for middle of the road anti heroes or an average Joe who is not remarkably nice or a jerk, and 10 is as close to perfect goodness as one can get. Where would you assume X-Characters would fall on that spectrum?

[Snoop Dogg]

Bill the Lobster = 10
WolverMean = 6
Magneto = 2
Iceman =8
Mystique = 0


that's it i'm tired i quit

[PsychoEFrost]

Going by the characters I like or strongly follow:

Laura Kinney: 8/10. About as paragon as someone can be while still occasionally killing. She doesn't want to, wants to move past that.

Nathan Summers: 4/10. Follow's the soldiers mantra: The ends justify the means. Whatever it takes to ensure his people and those under his protection survive.

Emma Frost: 3/10. Very much in the same area of "Ends justify the means", but taken to a degree even in her personal life.

Rachel Grey: 8/10. Heroic, but not without the choice to utterly destroy those who severely hurt her.

Scott Summers: 6/10. For all the talk of HitlerClops being a -100/10, the hate is overblown. He's not a bad person, just someone willing to make hard decisions.

Jean Grey: 8-9/10. Depending heavily on the writer. She can either be merciless to those who attack those who she protects to an extreme degree, or a paragon of absolute moral virtue.

[Glio]

The X-Men in general are 8 when things go well and during extinction events go down to 6.

[JudicatorPrime]

Morality? According to whom or what?

[Tycon]

Armor - 8
Rockslide - 7
Anole - 7
Dust - 6
Mercury - 8
Surge - 4
Hellion - 3
Prodigy - 5
Pixie - 9
Bling! - 7
Trance - 6
Elixir - 1
Loa - 5
Gentle - 9

Bill the Lobster = 10
WolverMean = 6
Magneto = 2
Iceman =8
Mystique = 0


that's it i'm tired i quit

i commend you for your service

[Snoop Dogg]

Anyone can win a fight-- When the odds-- are easy-- It's when the going's tough-- When there seems to be no chance-- That's when-- It counts!

Everything's going black-- My head-- Aching! Hold on-- I must hold on--!

Can't stop now! Last chance! Must keep the momentum-- More! Just a little more--!

Boom-Boom = 7

I did it!
I'm free!

[phoenixzero23]

Jean: 9 or 8
Cyclops: 6
Wolverine: 6
Storm: 10, she is perfect
Cable: 7
Nightcrawler: 9
Beast: 8
Rogue: 7
Psylocke: 7
Rachel: 8
Iceman: 8
Magneto: 5
Emma: 5
X-23: 8

[Omega Alpha]

Storm, the woman who mind-wiped Havok, considered murdering him, and let all the X-men's family and friends think they were dead, is perfect?

[phoenixzero23]

Storm, the woman who mind-wiped Havok, considered murdering him, and let all the X-men's family and friends think they were dead, is perfect?

Yes, she is. Those are nothing in comparisson to 99% of the X-men.

[Tycon]

Storm, the woman who mind-wiped Havok, considered murdering him, and let all the X-men's family and friends think they were dead, is perfect?

okay but did you ever consider that maybe havok deserved that?

[Snoop Dogg]

Storm is a 7 with Cyclops because she can go super hard, especially after that medieval heads on sticks **** she did with T'Challa in Secret Invasion. She's even willing to do the dirty work herself, but obviously opts not to whenever possible which puts her a cut above Wolverine, the 6.

[Maestroneto]

Storm ripped Marrow's heart out.

[Omega Alpha]

Storm is a 7 with Cyclops because she can go super hard, especially after that medieval heads on sticks **** she did with T'Challa in Secret Invasion. She's even willing to do the dirty work herself, but obviously opts not to whenever possible which puts her a cut above Wolverine, the 6.

Yep.

okay but did you ever consider that maybe havok deserved that?

No, he didn't. When Xavier does it, he's rightfully bashed.

[Tycon]

No, he didn't. When Xavier does it, he's rightfully bashed.

every senior X-Man should get three “**** with Havok” freebies. junior X-Men get one and a half.