Why is the animated adaption of the Dark Phoenix Saga the best adaption?

[The Overlord]

Why is the animated adaption of the Dark Phoenix Saga best adaption, where it was better than either movie adaption, despite being aimed at a younger audience?

https://www.cbr.com/x-men-animated-s...ampaign=CBR-TW

[yogaflame]

1) Jean and Scott's romantic relationship is well-established in the first and second SEASONS of the show.

2) The X-Men's familial relationship is well-established over the first two season, showing them encounter all manner of adventures and come back together despite it all.

3) The Shi'Ar are slowly introduced, first with the Soul-Eater(a definite departure from the comics, but it works) coming to the Morlock tunnels early in season 3.

4) The Phoenix saga is not skimped over. Jean's noble sacrifice to save the X-Men in the shuttle reentry is well executed, and they give her time to flourish into her power, have great showings against Gladiator, and go on to save the universe from D'Ken. It's almost like they weren't sure they were going to get another season to do the DPS, though, as they kinda have Jean 'sacrifice' herself by taking the M'Kraan Crystal into the sun(which kinda replicates the period where Scott thought Jean and Beast died in Magneto's volcano lair).

5) Their actual DPS episodes follow the main plot points from the original, despite not going too in depth with Mastermind's 2 year long manipulation of Jean as was done in the comics. Other than that, though, despite having a different cast of characters in play(Rogue, Gambit, etc.), they lean into that Claremont/Byrne goodness(Hellfire Club and Imperial Guard included) for full effect.

6) Despite changing things like the extent of Phoenix's destruction out in space(an uninhabited star system instead of billions dead), and not actually keeping her dead for longer than 2 minutes on the moon(maybe a bit closer to Claremont's original intention), it is wonderfully adapted for children, without dumbing it down too much.

[Digifiend]

5) Their actual DPS episodes follow the main plot points from the original, despite not going too in depth with Mastermind's 2 year long manipulation of Jean as was done in the comics. Other than that, though, despite having a different cast of characters in play(Rogue, Gambit, etc.), they lean into that Claremont/Byrne goodness(Hellfire Club and Imperial Guard included) for full effect.

They were able to quite easily substitute the characters. Beast and Nightcrawler are both acrobatic wallcrawlers, so Hank subbed in for Kurt. Rogue has super strength, so she had Colossus's role. Despite not having the same powers, Jubilee usually substituted for Kitty - except in Days of Future Past, which used Bishop instead.

[baltiroo]

The X-Men animated series was the best adaptation of the Dark Phoenix storyline for various reasons. They had more room to develop it and make it feel like a true natural progression like Claremont did in his run. And while they had to make some executive decisions on roles of who was available to be used they made it work really well. Best version we've gotten so far.

[phoenixzero23]

The story requires a lot of build up. The characters and their relationships need to be development and sadly the films haven't care about those relationships or have rushed them.
The animated version isn't perfect but it has more space to develop the characters.

[CRaymond]

How much build up is really necessary? All you need is a strong opening number that establishes the status quo that 1. the X-Men are powered superheroes led by a telepath 2. Jean is the weakest operative and 3. She’s in an awkward love affair with the teacher’s pet.

You don’t need Shi’Ar cosmic forces. You just need Jean to unlock insane power levels after a death event, and the subsequent dismantling of relationships with men who are uncomfortable with the amount of power in her hands.

The quadruple reveal that Xavier was really-not-that-bad-and-actually-good-all-along was the worst part of Dark Phoenix 2019.

[RachelGrey]

I even liked the Wolverine and the X-Men DPS, it reinterpreted the story but kept a large number of elements from the comic. TAS DPS is better definitely but I have a soft spot for the WatXM version too!

It's really sad that X3 and Dark Phoenix just couldn't do the DPS justice.

[yogaflame]

I can't stand WatXM's version. Jean is a pawn like in X3, and the entire team dynamics are all wrong.

[PsychoEFrost]

I can't stand WatXM's version. Jean is a pawn like in X3, and the entire team dynamics are all wrong.

You won't find me agreeing with you and disagreeing with RachelGrey very much, but here we are.

I have a soft spot for the WatXM series, since Kari Wahlgren is a FLAWLESS Emma Frost, but Scott, Jean, and Emma are mistreated so badly by the story that it's hard to enjoy it. I especially don't like them going with the "Phoenix is a force of death with no other redeeming qualities" angle.

[Snoop Dogg]

TAS only wins because it had more Leland. WaTXM is not an adaptation.

[U.N. Owen]

I can't stand WatXM's version. Jean is a pawn like in X3, and the entire team dynamics are all wrong.

And the lack of buildup, improper character focus outside of Wolverine really, butchering some characters, making the Phoenix stupidly wimpy (seriously, releasing it into the atmosphere? Get the pre-established weakness but that was pathetic), the Hellfire Club weren't even badass, and more.

[Snoop Dogg]

i miss leland man

[Killerbee911]

1. The X-men would be better as TV show than movie (see heroes first two seasons). So longer format for story telling is better for the X-men. X-men movies tried to tell Phoenix story in 2 hour movie. The X-men cartoon told the Phoenix story in a 5 part The Phoenix Saga and 4 part The Dark Phoenix Saga which adds up to about 3 hours plus some change.


2. X-men Phoenix is story is big and over top . And the X-men movies want to tell a "grounded" a story about cosmic alien firebird entity.

3. X-men animated series just told story tweaked for their format. Fox never really respected the X-men as a story. Which is why I am happy its last movie is failing spectacularly.They keep approaching X-men story on the big screen like they had to fix the stories instead of adapting for format

-We can't use alien firebird entity we have to fix it
-We can't use the Hellfire club we have to fix it
-We can't use the Shiar we have to fix it
-We can't show Jean really killing people and planets we have to fix it

I am happy that X-men is back with Marvel where the Red skull is guardian entity of the soul stone and nobody bats an eye how ridiculous that is, 11 foot purple man who is putting together magic stones to make half the universe disappear,Talking tree and Talking raccoon are around, A God jumps into a star to forge a magic axe and the talking tree becomes the handle.Nobody talks about how ridiculous that is and how you need to ground it. A S&M gear wearing secret club of rich mutants,Aliens and cosmic alien firebird entity fit right in. Yeah maybe tone down Hellfire to a secret club or not touch M'krann crystal all that other stuff but just stick to story it works.

[PsychoEFrost]

1. The X-men would be better as TV show than movie (see heroes first two seasons). So longer format for story telling is better for the X-men. X-men movies tried to tell Phoenix story in 2 hour movie. The X-men cartoon told the Phoenix story in a 5 part The Phoenix Saga and 4 part The Dark Phoenix Saga which adds up to about 3 and half hours.


2. X-men Phoenix is story is big and over top . And the X-men movies want to tell a "grounded" a story about cosmic alien firebird entity.

3. X-men animated series just told story tweaked for their format. Fox never really respected the X-men as story. Which is why I am happy its last movie is failing spectacularly.They keep approaching X-men story on the big screen like they had to fix the stories instead of adapting for format

-We can't use alien firebird entity we have to fix it
-We can't use the Hellfire club we have to fix it
-We can't use the Shiar we have to fix it
-We can't show Jean really killing people and planets we have to fix it

I am happy that X-men is back with Marvel where the Red skull is guardian entity of the soul stone and nobody bats an eye how ridiculous that is, 11 foot purple man who putting together magic stones to make half the universe disappear,Talking tree,Talking raccoon, A God jumps into a star to forge a magic axe and the tree becomes the handle.Nobody talks about how ridiculous that is and how you need to ground it. A S&M gear wearing secret club of rich mutants,Aliens and cosmic alien firebird entity fit right in

Give this user a hammer, because you nailed it.

[yogaflame]

I'm still mad at First Class for making what could be the X-Men's Eyes Wide Shut Illuminati stand in into a cheap Vegas strip joint.