Originally Posted by
SiegePerilous02
Superman definitely. All-Star is my favorite Superman story period, pretty much the Holy Bible of the character, and his New 52 Action run is the best modernized origin the character has ever had. It perfectly meshes the Golden and Silver Age takes. Aside from the less than stellar Jim Lee costume, I think it could remain pretty timeless and be uses as the default Superman origin going forward. Sucks that DC ditched it for no reason. I have zero problem envisioning that Superman growing into the current, wiser version who is married and has a kid.
Batman is a very close second. He writes the best Bat-God, because 1. He still makes Batman fun while doing it, and 2. He writes EVERYONE as a top tier God, so nobody gets thrown under the bus for Batman. His Batman, which channeled the Bronze Age quite a bit, was a breath of fresh air after years of Bruce being a one note, boring grouch. I disliked the run (and Damian) at first because of the focus on his new villains instead of the old ones, but I've re-read it a few times and now it is among my favorites. Also helps that he's one of the best things to happen to Dick Grayson.
His run with Hal is shaping up to be one of the best runs for the character. Every issue is a joy to read, albeit some more so than others. I read his brief run with Millar on Wally, and while good, I don't think it was long enough to be either his best or the best for the franchise. I do hope he gets an extended Flash run with Barry at some point.
Wonder Woman, as always with her and creators, is the outlier. He did alright by her in JLA, but there is Final Crisis and the Earth One books are more interesting failures than successes. He brings back the Golden Age elements and gives them some much needed criticism, but the problem is that he spends more time criticizing than modernizing/focusing on what worked. The Amazons are not the most unsympathetic Amazons we've seen (that would be the New 52), but they are far from the best they could be as well. And I feel like there are too many ideas squeezed into two books that he can't properly develop all of them. Many WW fans would probably not want it, but I would love an ongoing lengthy run instead of short graphic novels, but it would probably be better with a co-author like Rucka, and they could balance each other out. On the positive side, whatever can be said about his writing for Hippolyta at least she's actively present and not wallpaper like in the Azzarello run, and he gave us the best versions of Etta, Dr. Psycho and Paula von Gunther and they need to be transplanted to the main DCU immediately.
And hell yes, I want to see him tackle Aquaman and Captain Marvel, and even the Titans to get them out of their godawful rut.