Henry "Beast" McCoy vs Knuckles the Echidna

[Ultra_Sonic]

Round I) Primary canon versions only (Game Knuckles--minus Sonic Boom, due to Boom being an alternate reality from the main games and the fact that the Boom games, cartoon, and comics are all part of the same canon--vs. Earth-616 Beast)

Round II) Animated versions* (Composite).

Round III) Sonic Boom Knuckles vs. MCU Beast (X-Men films)

Bonus: IDW era Knuckles vs. Dark Beast (Earth-295/Age of Apocalypse)

*This is where things get confusing, as while the Sonic X Archie Comics series is confirmed to be a part of the Sonic X anime canon, it is ALSO considered to be a legitimate and official part of the greater Pre-Super Genesis Wave Archie Comics multiverse

[The Arbiter]

Generally speaking, most versions of Knuckles should out perform Hank.

Knuckles makes a habit of lifting and tossing huge boulders, smashing thick metal or stone to pieces and so on.

I know Hank is a decent brick, but Knuckles (the versions I know) tend to outperform.

[Cthulhu_of_R'lyeh]

Generally speaking, most versions of Knuckles should out perform Hank.

Knuckles makes a habit of lifting and tossing huge boulders, smashing thick metal or stone to pieces and so on.

I know Hank is a decent brick, but Knuckles (the versions I know) tend to outperform.

Knuckles is also a brick, but it's because he's as dense as one.

[master of read]

Knuckles is also a brick, but it's because he's as dense as one.

well archie comics knux was actually a good bit smarter than his other incarnations. still a bit gullible but not rock stupid. especially when his people return and his parents, teammate, and girlfriend was around.

[Agent Z]

well archie comics knux was actually a good bit smarter than his other incarnations. still a bit gullible but not rock stupid. especially when his people return and his parents, teammate, and girlfriend was around.

I think most versions of Knuckles are at least smarter than the Sonic Boom version.

[The Drunkard Kid]

How fast are the non-game versions of Knuckles, since the game versions are also at least in Sonic' s general ballpark when it comes to running speed?

[Len Ikari145]

well archie comics knux was actually a good bit smarter than his other incarnations. still a bit gullible but not rock stupid. especially when his people return and his parents, teammate, and girlfriend was around.

Hell, Archie Knuckles was stated to be a certified genius in terms of academics, according to his dad.

[master of read]

Hell, Archie Knuckles was stated to be a certified genius in terms of academics, according to his dad.

yup. he still got tricked on occasion but that was mostly due to him being alone most of his life and not having much of an idea on who to trust. but once he sussed out who to actually trust, he didn't fall into it again.

also, he has to be smart to stay with julie-su

[The MunchKING]

Knuckles is also a brick, but it's because he's as dense as one.

The Only problem is that Knuckles isn't very bright.