Star Wars vs. Asgard (MCU)

[The Arbiter]

The forces from "Episode 1: The Phantom Menace" versus the Kingdom of Asgard before Hela/Surtur mess it up.

All of Naboo's fighters + Gungan army. 1 Trade Federation ship in low orbit + all droid forces seen. Obi Wan, Quigon and Darth Maul.

Versus:

Asgard starts with its castle shield up + all its standing armies scrambled. Odin is in charge. Loki and Thor (with Mjolnir) are present.

Important notes: The 3 Force users start INSIDE the palace. They are charged with shutting the shield down. The main Asgardians are likewise inside the palace throne room. They are aware of the attack, but not the jedi.

Can they topple Asgard's rule?

[big_adventure]

No, they have no real chance of winning here. Asgardians are too good and too tough.

The SW forces aren't ever getting through the shield: remember, it took a being stronger and tougher than Thor, with nasty energy draining magic touch, to pound down the defenses around the shield generator. Nothing about these guys makes them immune to Heimdall either, so he'll see them coming and know exactly where they are. Honestly, given his abilities, there is no real reason that he can't just Bifrost them the hell out of the palace and on over to, say, Jotunheim, without them ever knowing what he's up to.

For the rest of the forces, their base-level blasters are things Asgardians can probably no-sell as well.

And this is before Thor and Odin start doing their thing. Thor's AoE's are going to leave acres of corpses and droid parts to pick up.

[Stigmazilla]

No, they have no real chance of winning here. Asgardians are too good and too tough.

The SW forces aren't ever getting through the shield: remember, it took a being stronger and tougher than Thor, with nasty energy draining magic touch, to pound down the defenses around the shield generator. Nothing about these guys makes them immune to Heimdall either, so he'll see them coming and know exactly where they are. Honestly, given his abilities, there is no real reason that he can't just Bifrost them the hell out of the palace and on over to, say, Jotunheim, without them ever knowing what he's up to.

For the rest of the forces, their base-level blasters are things Asgardians can probably no-sell as well.

And this is before Thor and Odin start doing their thing. Thor's AoE's are going to leave acres of corpses and droid parts to pick up.

Pretty much this you'd need 6o remove Thor, Odin and probably Loki and give them at least Episode Two levels of forces

[moonknight11]

Pretty much this you'd need 6o remove Thor, Odin and probably Loki and give them at least Episode Two levels of forces

episode two would be a stomp the other way. the clones and droids were packing serious heat in that one.

but yeah, i dont recall ep 1 battle being that impressive.

[k von doom]

Yeah, SW would need the combined Episode 2 forces of Loyalist and Resistance armies to stand a chance.

[big_adventure]

Yeah, SW would need the combined Episode 2 forces of Loyalist and Resistance armies to stand a chance.

Even then, can they dent Thor's armor? Nothing they have done says "yes" to that.