Which post-Bendis flagship title has been the worst?

[nightw1ng]

I think for me, it's Gold. Most of the time, I just found it boring, disappointing, and a waste of time. And as a Rachel fan, I hated how Guggenheim made her look pathetic. Don't get me wrong, Rosenberg's Uncanny X-Men was a train wreck from start to finish, but I enjoyed it on a sort of morbid level. Perhaps knowing Hickman was coming and that all the death and misery wouldn't actually matter made it more palatable.

[Celgress]

OP Question - Uncanny X-Men is the worst of the bunch, IMO

[BroHomo]

I cant believe Gold isn't winning by a landslide lol. Rosenbergs uncanny reads like a comic book version of Bad Girls Club... Dog the bounty Hunter...or Aurora Teagarden mysteries...its trash and no one wants to admit to liking trash but each week they're back to see the refuse pile up

[stormphoenix]

X-Men Gold by Guggenheim was UTTER TRASH!!!!

[Dante Milton]

The worst thing about Gold and Extraordinary was that they were boring, Uncanny was offensively bad. The Syaf controversy was the only thing about Gold that was similarly offensive and Marvel pretty quickly corrected that by firing him. Too bad Rosenberg wasn’t similarly dealt with after his incredibly insensitive suicide story and trans panic murder.

[Triniking1234]

Are 20 people sour that Lemire used Venom as a Horseman of Apocalypse?

lol

[Snoop Dogg]

Are 20 people sour that Lemire used Venom as a Horseman of Apocalypse?

lol

remember when deadpool became the pain from mgs3 for two seconds, that was cool

EXM also had the de la soul variant, that's like an extra 10 points

gold had a very good del mundo queen variant but that implied more kittylossus so no points

[Killerbee911]

I cant believe Gold isn't winning by a landslide lol. Rosenbergs uncanny reads like a comic book version of Bad Girls Club... Dog the bounty Hunter...or Aurora Teagarden mysteries...its trash and no one wants to admit to liking trash but each week they're back to see the refuse pile up

From Rosenberg twitter

12 issues of Uncanny X-Men came out in the last 6 months. All 12 were the best selling or 2nd best selling @Marvel comic on @comiXology each week. I know this comes off as bragging, but honestly I really just wanted to thank all the X-Fans for the support one last time

The numbers order from the shop wasn't bad, It looks it did well online. You are probably right

[Nick Miller]

3 years from now

“Which hickman era book was the worst?”

Topaz
Uncanny
X-Alted

Lol

[Omega Alpha]

From Rosenberg twitter


The numbers order from the shop wasn't bad, It looks it did well online. You are probably right

It was the only X-men book in the 616, featuring Cyclops and Wolverine.

[FluffyCyclopsRLZ]

3 years from now

“Which hickman era book was the worst?”

Topaz
Uncanny
X-Alted

Lol

I'll raise you. "That line-wide relaunch with the B-Z listers would've totally done better if Marvel had promoted it better!'

[spirit2011]

I think for me, it's Gold. Most of the time, I just found it boring, disappointing, and a waste of time. And as a Rachel fan, I hated how Guggenheim made her look pathetic. Don't get me wrong, Rosenberg's Uncanny X-Men was a train wreck from start to finish, but I enjoyed it on a sort of morbid level. Perhaps knowing Hickman was coming and that all the death and misery wouldn't actually matter made it more palatable.

Gold did nothing.

At least Rosenberg tried something

[Triniking1234]

What did Rosenberg try exactly?

At least Guggs put the toys back before he dipped.

[Silver Fang]

Gold and Bergcanny were both terrible.

But I think Rosenberg's Uncanny edges it out due to all the unneeded deaths, and characters written so bad they were embarrassing. lol

Guggenheim wasn't good with continuity. KittyLossus had moved on long ago, and there was no need to bring it back Now it won't go away. Just like Aaron's ignorant ass with Crystique. Gold was heavily flawed, but it just never seemed as bad as what Rosenberg is capable of. Gotta give it to him on overall "story" and characterization.

Rosenberg is now tied with Pak for ruining my favorites.

[nx01a]

The first half of Rosenberg's Uncanny was enjoyable, if dark. Things really went off the rails in the second half.

Extraordinary was bogged down with too much editorial drama, like Bunn's Blue and Uncanny, but at least it was mildly enjoyable. Sapna WHO?!

I'm not sure I can say I really enjoyed any of X-Men: Kitty Pryde Gold Edition. I'll vote for Gold.