Whitebeard vs. Big Mom

[Jcogginsa]

Pretty simple: It's Yonkou vs. Yonkou.

The Adopted Father vs. the Awful Mother.

Who takes the win?

[Lord Falcon]

Big Mom just doesn't have the kinds of feats Whitebeard has. Kaido might turn out to be a good match, but Big Mom isn't.

She's massively strong and durable, no doubt, but Whitebeard is plainly stronger than her (stopping a charging ship one-handed when already mostly dead, creating massive gales enough to fill the sky with marines just with one normal swing) and his Quake Quake fruit is perfect for wrecking her durability.

[Jcogginsa]

Big Mom just doesn't have the kinds of feats Whitebeard has. Kaido might turn out to be a good match, but Big Mom isn't.

She's massively strong and durable, no doubt, but Whitebeard is plainly stronger than her (stopping a charging ship one-handed when already mostly dead, creating massive gales enough to fill the sky with marines just with one normal swing) and his Quake Quake fruit is perfect for wrecking her durability.

Big Mom does have good offense though thanks to Zeus and Prometheus

[Dark Soul # 7]

Big Mom does have a bit of a versetility edge thanks to Zeus and Prometheus.

But Whitebeard beats her out in raw strength.

He should win, but it'll probably hurt afterwards.

[Lord Falcon]

Zeus and Prometheus will put the hurt on, but it's nothing Whitebeard hasn't amply shown he's capable of fighting through. Both of them are massive tanks with great offensive power, but Whitebeard is both physically stronger, more skilled (Big Mom is just a brute) and has the more devastating range game.

Furthermore, Big Mom's insane durability is balanced out by the fact that her damage soak once that durability is bypassed isn't that great. Simply falling to her knees when her durability was down caused her knees to bleed, and having a brachiosaurus divebombed into her head was enough to knock her out. Now, there's no shame in getting knocked out by a massive dinosaur to the head, but Whitebeard literally was stabbed straight through the chest by a giant sword, shot hundreds of times including taking multiple bazookas to the face, was shot several times by Kizaru's lasers, got his torso pumped full of lava, got almost half his head blown off by more lava, and after all that still split a fortress island in half and beat down a fresh Blackbeard mano-a-mano. He will eat anything Big Mom can dish out and hit back harder.

But yes, he'll definitely be feeling it afterwards. Big Mom's standard punches are equivalent to Luffy's Gear 4 punches. Just one Gear 4 punch was enough to nearly take out Donflamingo right then and there, sending him flying across his kingdom to crater into a mountain. Big Mom's punches will hurt.

[wjowski]

Not to mention Whitebeard's probably not dying from illness in this fight.