Fellowship of the Ring (plus Tauriel, Faramir, and Eomer) vs. CW Green Arrow and Nolanverse Batman
Fight takes place in Rivendell. Everyone has their gear and weapons. Frodo cannot use the Ring and Gandalf cannot use magic. Even though it's the Council of Elrond, the Fellowship and friends have feats until end of trilogy.
No one has prep. Participants start from 50 feet away. Who wins?