The case for/against the name Ric

[tib2d2]

Lots of strong feelings about Nightwing's alter ego being Ric or Dick. I don't read the series, only heard things on these boards and on comic news sites.

Certainly Dick is an old fashioned name that no one names their kids anymore. I'm still surprised older men still go by it TBH, but hey its your name right?

So, does it stand to reason that a younger man would prefer to go by another nickname for Richard besides Dick? Or it his name too entrenched in tradition and history that its blasphemous to change it in 2019?

[Clark_Kent]

I'll catch a lot of hell for it, but I'm one of the 2 people on the planet who doesn't care. I'm not liking this amnesia direction, but I care nothing for whether he wants to go by Dick or Ric. When he's eventually himself again, if he continues to go by Ric then I don't care as long as his character depiction is right. I think the arguments and outrage over the name are a bit silly myself, though to each their own.

[Tzigone]

I think Ric is dead in the water because of the amnesia storyline.

I think he's always gone by Dick, and even if it is old fashioned, there's really no reason to change it. Roy and Wally and Lois are old-fashioned, too. Dick, admittedly, will result in a snort or laughter from some at first, but then you quit even thinking about it. Dick Grayson has name recognition, and that's not nothing.

If he was going to go by something else, Richard (which they already tried) or Rick would be better than Ric, which is far less common and more likely to be seen as faddish, dated or silly in the future.

[tib2d2]

Well IMO, if tomorrow DC announced that Nightwing is done with whatever amnesia he has, and from this moment forth he's going by "Rick Grayson", I would be completely onboard.

[Vakanai]

Ric is a better name than Dick, nobody, and I mean absolutely nobody the age Grayson is supposed to be goes by the name Dick. That said I'd prefer Rick or Rich or skipping nicknames altogether and just using Richard. Even if Ric was okay, that name is now tainted by such a horrible mess of a run. So Ric is out of the question because of the story told with it, but Dick really needs to go as a name. It is outdated, and only works as a believable nickname for him if you age him up to be a baby boomer.

[Tzigone]

but Dick really needs to go as a name.

Strongly disagree. He's Dick Grayson. That's me, that's who he is. Even if it is old-fashioned.

Would I create a new character today and call him Dick - no. But he's not a new character, and I don't want to change his (nick)name. There's just no way for it not to feel false if done in the comic at this point.

I dont know anyone under 40 (at least) who goes by Dick. No one the age Dick Grayson is supposed to be would use that name. However, there's far too much history behind the name to make changing it a good idea.

You said it better.

[Pohzee]

I can see the case that Dick is outdated. I don't agree with it, but I see it.

But Ric? Ric is even worse. No offense to anyone who may be named that way, but that's the dumbest way to spell it.

That stupid, cutesy spelling ensured that it would never stick.

[Ascended]

Lots of strong feelings about Nightwing's alter ego being Ric or Dick. I don't read the series, only heard things on these boards and on comic news sites.

Certainly Dick is an old fashioned name that no one names their kids anymore. I'm still surprised older men still go by it TBH, but hey its your name right?

So, does it stand to reason that a younger man would prefer to go by another nickname for Richard besides Dick? Or it his name too entrenched in tradition and history that its blasphemous to change it in 2019?

Yes to both.

I dont know anyone under 40 (at least) who goes by Dick. No one the age Dick Grayson is supposed to be would use that name. However, there's far too much history behind the name to make changing it a good idea.

However, as a fan I wouldn't be against the idea if, like tib2d2 said, if DC wrapped up the "Ric" story, Dick got his memories back, became Nightwing again, and just went by "Rick" I'd be okay with it. The "Ric" spelling is stupid as sh*t and will become dated far more quickly than Dick did, but "Rick" wouldn't be the worst thing. But in all honesty I don't think even that minor change would stick. Dick Grayson is Dick Grayson and trying to change his name after eighty damn years isn't going to be any more successful than changing Bruce Wayne's.