Quote Originally Posted by tuck frump View Post
I wonder if maybe Kitty isnt fully onboard with the whole Krakoa project and maybe not even living on the island at all and thats why Emma picks her to be a voice of dissent and why her inclusion is a mystery in universe.
We did see her planting a flower in HoX #1 but maybe she disageed with some of Xavier's decisions which would be on brand.
The flower planting doesn't preclude them from later depicting her as not on board with Krakoa, but with all the setup Hickman did for Marauders elsewhere in HOXPOX, it's hard to imagine why he would have written Kitty into that sequence in the first place if Kitty's role was going to be as a Krakoa skeptic. (It's not like Marauders took shape in between writing HOX #1 and POX #5; I think Duggan and White have said Marauders has been in development for a year.)

Also we've seen on the Krakoa map that Hellfire Bay has a "Red Keep", so if Kitty isn't living on Krakoa at the start of Marauders, I bet it doesn't take her long to relocate.