Phoenix ressurection was nice, jean made me tear up a bit at the end.
Iconic self.
Uncanny X-men(Bendis)
Uncanny X-men(Bunn)
Uncanny X-men disassembled
Uncanny X-men(Rosenberg)
All new X-men(Bendis)
X-men Gold
X-men Blue
X-men Red
Death of Wolverine
Phoenix Resurrection
Astonishing X-men vol. 4
Amazing X-men
X-men
Wolverine and the X-men
Others
Phoenix ressurection was nice, jean made me tear up a bit at the end.
Iconic self.
I voted Others, my pick is AvX Consequences. It was able to pick me up after the hollow victory of AvX. I was suddenly excited to read about a revolutionary Cyclops. I also liked X-Men, Wolverine and the X-Men, All New and Uncanny at least until Battle of the Atom. Then things seem to fall apart.
The Bendis Books haf big flaws but I was entertained and looked forward to the next issue at times.
But my Gold Standard is still Spurrier XML. Cable and XF was fun. Amazing and Bunncanny had some neat parts.
Le Suck it, Dolphin!
-God I am so tired.
SCOTT SUMMERS AND EMMA FROST DESERVED BETTER.
Magneto by Bunn followed by Si Spurriers Legacy run.
Nothing can convince me otherwise.
Uncanny Avengers absolutely - A book about getting Xaviers brain out of the RED SKULLS noggin' is the best X-BOOK in my book.
I also enjoyed;
Uncanny X-men (Bunn) (but had no business being called Uncanny X-men, imo)
Uncanny X-men disassembled (Rockslide and Pixie, ftw)
Phoenix Resurrection
Astonishing X-men vol. 4
Parts of;
Uncanny X-men (Rosenberg)
X-men Blue
Wolverine and the X-men
X-men Gold
But can't remember anything of;
Uncanny X-men (Bendis)
All new X-men (Bendis)
Amazing X-men
X-men (Which one is this?)
of all that loooong period I only really really liked the ghost Jean/Jeen/Emma story. The rest is rubbish. The tacky X Men 90s period and this post AvX period are the X Men at their lowest. Now there seems to be hope with HoX/PoX...
Primum vivere deindre philosophare
IMO the best of these is X-Men Red, which is the best X-Men book since AvX (before Hickman). That said, All-New by Bendis was an excellent guilty pleasure, really fun, just wish he had finished what he started, I strongly disliked the O5 staying at the end of his run and that made all books after it worse. I didn't read Uncanny by Bendis, but the other books had too much involvement of the terrible status of the mutants in the Marvel universe. WatXM was good but felt like a smaller sidebook.
Spurrier's Legacy and X-Force runs were the best.
X-Men Red was the best of the options on the poll, but it was really only okay, I would rank Jean Grey, Gen-X v.2, Iceman, Lui's Astonishing, All New X-Factor, and All New X-Men v.2 (Hopeless) higher than Red.