X-Men #1 Discussion Thread [Spoilers]

[CoCoBandz]

The hell did Scott do that he needed forgiveness? By Logan of all people?

Didn't share Jean fast enough?

[phoenixzero23]

oh god, the fact that Logan is living with the Summers and sharing the room with jean and cyclops had been anticipated in power of x # 4. That of the relationship between the three of them is not so far from reality, Sinister says that Logan has a relationship with Jean and Cyclops knows it, but Cyclops does not point the finger since he actively participates
spoilers:

Attachment 88351

end of spoilers

Well yeah, but that is what happened on Morrison's run. Why do it again?

[spirit2011]

They weren't really ok with each other until this. Rosenberg's run amicable relationship was all Emma's doing.

they were really ok working together, then they had a fall out, so on the last issue they were really ok with dying together. two good colleagues

[Veitha]

A cerebro isn't need. Just another way of doing mind back ups;

the guy blew himself for nothing, what a idiot. hhaa

Cap america there was ressurrection, but via magic

I assumed Cerebro tech was somewhat special in saving a mind, but I guess other mind backups are possible.

[Astroman]

I hope we get a flashback to Scott and Logan talking Jean into fucking both of them.

I'm hoping more for a Scott and Jean convincing Logan who is just, "Wait, you two really AREN'T just messing with my head?!?!?"

[spirit2011]

Scott watching Logan die: Bravest man I know.
Scott talking to Corsair: I live in this house surrounded by the people I love.

Theyre colleagues who from time to time jack off in front of each oher while maintaining eye contact.

you can love a colleague

IDK why everyhting is about sex with x-men readers

Well yeah, but that is what happened on Morrison's run. Why do it again?

That is why the secret refers to other people. Just repeat the same story and get it even worse, would be overkill

[Fokken]

The hell did Scott do that he needed forgiveness? By Logan of all people?

C'mon, for real? Logan blamed Scott for tons of stuff.
I think he may have even blamed him for Kurt dying back in Second Coming. Also Chuck's death, etc etc. I mean, the list is pretty long between those two for their respective perceived slights.

[CoCoBandz]

you can love a colleague

IDK why everyhting is about sex with x-men readers

We weren't always like this...

[KangMiRae]

So was that Sinister's diamond that Dr. Gregor made at the end?

[Veitha]

C'mon, for real? Logan blamed Scott for tons of stuff.
I think he may have even blamed him for Kurt dying back in Second Coming. Also Chuck's death, etc etc. I mean, the list is pretty long between those two for their respective perceived slights.

He even resented him for being with Emma lol. Logan used to wait for reasons to hate Scott.

8504ee58d7d6e81b1e63accaeedea2c9.jpg

This is what happened last time Logan had access to Scott's room

[Havok83]

C'mon, for real? Logan blamed Scott for tons of stuff.
I think he may have even blamed him for Kurt dying back in Second Coming. Also Chuck's death, etc etc. I mean, the list is pretty long between those two for their respective perceived slights.

Beast is the one that blamed Scott for Kurt's death, not Logan. Charles dying was not an attack on Logan and not anything Scott needed to seek forgiveness for. Scott killed him while possessed by the Phoenix Force. Wolverine killed Northstar while brainwashed by the Hand. If anyone should have been understanding, it should have been him

[spirit2011]

I assumed Cerebro tech was somewhat special in saving a mind, but I guess other mind backups are possible.

Maybe not a perfect back up, but ORCHIS has the best scientists in the world

Also: all those apes have PHDs

LOL that was a fun line

We weren't always like this...

yeah, everyone act like SEX is the most important thing ever and that it can trump characterization and relationships

[Veitha]

So was that Sinister's diamond that Dr. Gregor made at the end?

Too pink. Probably Nimrod related.

[Nevets]

Sigh....we're a long way from New X-men.

Praise Krakoa!

[HomoSuperior]

Good issue.

RE: Artwork. Not a fan of Yu. Never have been, really. No disrespect but Yu’s work is too stiff for Hickman’s action scenes and optimistic tone. Krakoa’s scenery was a dud. Camera angles are flat. Body language and anatomy are rigid and weird. Faces are creepy, in an awkward way, with eyes blacked/scratched out. Something about Polaris’ head dress was distracting. Hickman is setting characters up for some great moments, but Yu’s work makes it difficult to connect with the characters. Can we get Pepe Larraz or RB Silva back, ASAP, please?

RE: Cyclops / Polaris. Some are saying their exchange hints at possible romance between the two. I don’t see it. I saw it as Cyclops floating that Alex was available. Polaris responding “when the past is the past and I’m not still finding my way in a new land” sounds like she wants to focus on developing an identity that isn’t “Havok’s mentally ill girlfriend.” Hope Hickman makes good on that.

RE: Dr Gregor. I wonder if she somehow got hold of resurrection tech via Mystique, before Mystique went out the airlock? If Xavier leads Mystique on, I could see Mystique leaking the tech in order to bring Destiny back.