X-Men Week Day 6

[powerpax]

Nice guy with some nice/bad ideas and largely bland execution.

[PsychoEFrost]

If somebody was punished it was jean even unfairly. She was the sexual abuse victim and still sacrificed herself



Hickman crafted this story, nothing is coincidence. He wanted to forgive and forget Emma crimes, so he did it

He also did the same for Xavier, Magneto, Mystique, Apocalypse, Mister Sinister, and others and I would love to hear how they're so much more innocent than Emma.

[spirit2011]

He also did the same for Xavier, Magneto, Mystique, Apocalypse, Mister Sinister, and others and I would love to hear how they're so much more innocent than Emma.

Magneto isn't a villain for 15 years. I already said that I'm against villains on krakoa

[powerpax]

As some of us have discussed in other threads today, Emma's forgiveness was always built in - she was grief-stricken and unstable, etc. That is just another Tuesday for most X-Men gone bad in the past.

[PsychoEFrost]

Magneto isn't a villain for 15 years. I already said that I'm against villains on krakoa

Neither is Emma. She was a villain during the worst written period of X-Men comics ever. At worst she was morally grey.

[spirit2011]

As some of us have discussed in other threads today, Emma's forgiveness was always built in - she was grief-stricken and unstable, etc. That is just another Tuesday for most X-Men gone bad in the past.

Grief just don't justify it. They weren't even together at that point and many months passed.

Neither is Emma. She was a villain during the worst written period of X-Men comics ever. At worst she was morally grey.

She was straight bad, she was going to rape teen Scott if wasn't for Jeen stoping her

[PsychoEFrost]

Grief just don't justify it. They weren't even together at that point and many months passed.



She was straight bad, she was going to rape teen Scott if wasn't for Jeen stoping her

I wasn't aware grief for someone you care about has a expiration date or a time table. My wife's dad passed away 2 years ago, and she still struggles with that. I guess she should just man up and get over it?

[TheCape]

Magneto isn't a villain for 15 years. I already said that I'm against villains on krakoa

Magneto still did pretty unforgivable things before that though. Of.we are giving him a pass because of that, then we shall give one to Emma, considering that she was in the good side since 1990 until 2016.

[spirit2011]

Magneto still did pretty unforgivable things before that though. Of.we are giving him a pass because of that, then we shall give one to Emma, considering that she was in the good side since 1990 until 2016.

I don't even think he should be a hero too. So I'm fine with it

I wasn't aware grief for someone you care about has a expiration date or a time table. My wife's dad passed away 2 years ago, and she still struggles with that. I guess she should just man up and get over it?

Grief is usually something that gets better with time, people have different ways to deal with it. Majority of people in grief doesn't go out there comiting mass murder and working with villain with that excuse

[Tycon]

I don't even think he should be a hero too. So I'm fine with it

Xavier, Gambit, Bishop, Forge, Magik, Angel, Kid Omega, Frenzy, and Beast have all done horrific stuff too. Should they still be heroes?

[Bafflement]

Wish Bunn had had more of a chance with the X-books. He handled a lot of characters well, and most of the negative aspects of his runs seem to have been inflicted by editorial. Turning the O5 into Exiles would have been a much better resolution for them than the continuity-warping one we received.

[H-E-D]

Nice guy with some nice/bad ideas and largely bland execution.

Yeah, pretty much my take as well.

[powerpax]

I was all for them turning the O5 into Exiles. But I also never liked the O5 stuff much to begin with.

[tuck frump]

If somebody was punished it was jean even unfairly. She was the sexual abuse victim and still sacrificed herself

Abuse is really no justification for the murder of billions of people. And killing oneself to avoid having to face consequences is not justice.

[spirit2011]

Abuse is really no justification for the murder of billions of people. And killing oneself to avoid having to face consequences is not justice.

I think in this case completely justified. It completely made her lose the control of the force she had.
And the force kills everything that stop revolution, a person out of control couldn't stop it.

and she killed herself because she couldn't imagine live with it