Fallen Angels #1 Preview

[JB]

Haha, good ol' Bunn.

[Beetle]

Rogue was competent leading

Was she? Half her team defected, Cable faked his death so he could kidnap a baby, and she wound up comatose and off the X-Men for like a year

[tuck frump]

Was she? Half her team defected, Cable faked his death so he could kidnap a baby, and she wound up comatose and off the X-Men for like a year

not tomention, her team was composed strictly of bigger idiots then her except for Cable and Mystique who both played her.

[spirit2011]

Was she? Half her team defected, Cable faked his death so he could kidnap a baby, and she wound up comatose and off the X-Men for like a year

every leader has failures, she was better on uncanny avengers

[Dthirds3]

GOD I hope that's not the version of Laura we get. While she had some badass moments she was just written horribly in Disassembled.

To be fair the fact the hill referenced NYX implies he looked in to her rather then assume shes wolverine with boobs should hint shell be written well

[JB]

every leader has failures, she was better on uncanny avengers

Rogue was great in Uncanny Avengers. Looked good on her.

[Havok83]

Rogue was competent leading

not as an X-man. She had one of the worst stints as leader in X-men history.

every leader has failures, she was better on uncanny avengers

Her failure was obvious though which made it worse. She had no valid reason to fill up her team with villians (Sabretooth, Mystique, Omega Sentinel and Lady Mastermind) and then act surprised when they all played her. Her entire stint as leader was a joke as she was made to look like a fool from day one and she wasnt able to redeem herself in that run

[PsychoEFrost]

every leader has failures, she was better on uncanny avengers

That's like saying she was better when written by Rosenberg or Guggenheim. Everyone on Uncanny Avengers was awful, with Wanda and Alex being the absolute worst culprits.

[Beetle]

Her failure was obvious though which made it worse. She had no valid reason to fill up her team with villians (Sabretooth, Mystique, Omega Sentinel and Lady Mastermind) and then act surprised when they all played her. Her entire stint as leader was a joke as she was made to look like a fool from day one and she wasnt able to redeem herself in that run

Karima wasn't a villain. She just has this unfortunate tendency to get possessed and manipulated by external forces which make her villainous against her will.

That's like saying she was better when written by Rosenberg or Guggenheim. Everyone on Uncanny Avengers was awful, with Wanda and Alex being the absolute worst culprits.

Not under Remender. She had a good stint with Duggan and Zub though

[Havok83]

Karima wasn't a villain. She just has this unfortunate tendency to get possessed and manipulated by external forces which make her villainous against her will.

h

Okay, same difference. She ultimately was used in a villian capacity as she almost always ends up. An omega sentinel should never be trusted and it was especially stupid of Rogue to invite a sentinel in the mansion after M-Day

[Beetle]

Okay, same difference. She ultimately was used in a villian capacity as she almost always ends up. An omega sentinel should never be trusted and it was especially stupid of Rogue to invite a sentinel in the mansion after M-Day

They already had sentinels parked on their front lawn

[Hi-Fi]

Her failure was obvious though which made it worse. She had no valid reason to fill up her team with villians (Sabretooth, Mystique, Omega Sentinel and Lady Mastermind) and then act surprised when they all played her. Her entire stint as leader was a joke as she was made to look like a fool from day one and she wasnt able to redeem herself in that run

Sabretooth was a prisioner, not a team member. Mystique was allowed inside the mansion (in a vote led by Cyclops) against Rogue's wishes. She didn't invite Karima. Cyclops and Emma brought Karima and Lady Mastermind to the mansion because they needed help after being found in one of Pandemic's labs. And Rogue took all these villains away from the school when she left with the team in the Conquistador. Plus she defeated the Children of the Vault and saved the world during Supernova.

[Perfection/Emma 2]

^ Exactly! Rogue did the best she could do in that situation and none of the X-Men were prepared for the betrayals. Also Karima was under the control of Malice

[tuck frump]

Sabretooth was a prisioner, not a team member. Mystique was allowed inside the mansion (in a vote led by Cyclops) against Rogue's wishes. She didn't invite Karima. Cyclops and Emma brought Karima and Lady Mastermind to the mansion because they needed help after being found in one of Pandemic's labs. And Rogue took all these villains away from the school when she left with the team in the Conquistador. Plus she defeated the Children of the Vault and saved the world during Supernova.

But do you think she's intelligent? When written in-character.

[JB]

Karima wasn't a villain. She just has this unfortunate tendency to get possessed and manipulated by external forces which make her villainous against her will.

My kinda Friday night.