2010
Winner: Red Dead Redemption 2
Runner Up: Mass Effect 2
Still Wanna Play: Fallout: New Vegas
2011
Winner: Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Runner Up: Batman: Arkham City
Still Wanna Play: LA Noire
2012
Winner: Journey
Runner Up: Telltale's The Walking Dead (Season One)
Still Wanna Play: Far Cry 3
2013
Winner: Batman: Arkham Origins
Runner Up: The Wolf Among Us
Still Wanna Play: Bioshock Infinite
2014
Winner: Middle Earth: Shadow of Mordor
Runner Up: Broken Age
Still Wanna Play: Alien Isolation (Finish it anyway!)
2015
Winner: Life Is Strange
Runner Up: Batman: Arkham Knight
Still Wanna Play: MGSV: The Phantom Pain
2016
Winner: Hitman
Runner Up: Firewatch
Still Wanna Play: Dishonored 2
2017
Winner: Horizon: Zero Dawn
Runner Up: Batman: The Enemy Within
Still Wanna Play: Prey
2018
Winner: Marvel's Spider-Man
Runner Up: Return of the Obra Din
Still Wanna Play: Assassin's Creed: Odyssey
2019
Winner: Star Wars: Jedi Fallen Order
Runner Up: Days Gone
Still Want To Play: The Outer Worlds