So how is it different from anything else? It's all in the realm of possibility. It's the exact same thing as saying "Mutants and humans can't live in peace because the plot demands." Or, in the case of HOX/POX, Hickman writing "All mutants are united because I say so."
In any case, I'm not engaging anymore; you're just looking for a fight and I won't give it.
Because one of the primary tenets of writing a story is to have your audience actively believe in the premise. If all your premise is defended by is "because I say so" then there is no audience investment.
And I'm not looking for a fight. You're the one arguing in every thread for the sake of being contrarian.
"Because plot" can be damned cheap sometimes.
Genkai nante nai (No limits), Zettai nante nai (No absolutes)
Thank GOD for X'97. Cautious about "From the Ashes". Please no more Blue vs. Orange.
No, he didn't. He spent all of HoX/PoX setting it up, and gave plausible reasons for why Krakoa works. It is heavily defended, it provides a reason for humans not to attack it, and provides a reason to be there. Your theoretical settlement has none of those aspects. If mutants could find shelter anywhere, Krakoa wouldn't be needed.
And yet it still amounted to "All mutants are united because I said so," "Moira is a mutant because I said so," He set up a retcon as much as he did an island.
Besides, who said anything about it working on a larger scale? It could happen, let's not discount there might be pockets where mutants might be alright and comfortable. Or they might just not wanna go.
It looks like Glob thought Armor was a buzzkill and decided to dance with Pixie.
"This is starting to sound like a bad comic book plot"
-Spider-man
“Evil is evil...lesser, greater, middling, it's all the same."
-Geralt of Rivia
Oh Duuuude No disrespect intended. My total Bad. It was a genuine observation and curiosity.
Hmm okay I guuuess I can see how you can read it that way. Thanks for answering
I mean I'm not saying Mutants outside of Krakoa can't be happy or pocket communities where Mutants can safely live are nonexistent...I mean they have to...I don't think eeeeerrrvrry mutant is on Krakoa..
GrindrStone(D)
It's funny how just a mutant wanting to see her former teammates join her homeland sparks up some controversy now when a few years ago the Inhumans were letting a cloud roam free around the world turning everyone into Inhumans and inviting them into their creepy monarchist society