November 2019 X-books sales

[RD155]

That is a complete shock to me to see Marauders outside of the top 10. Was expecting that to sell big and more then Fallen Angels for sure. Don’t get me wrong, I’m happy for Fallen Angels but definitely didn’t expect it to sell well.

[Nazrel]

That is a complete shock to me to see Marauders outside of the top 10. Was expecting that to sell big and more then Fallen Angels for sure.

Number 1's don't count, and #1 Marauders came out in October.

Edit: It was in the top 10.

[cranger]

Arent you being a bit over entusiastic about numbers 1?

Not to disagree, but X-Men #2 did do better than ASM. Yes, still too early, but still not a bad sign either.

[Askani5]

Not on top 10.

Wow I’m surprise New Mutants took the number 1 spot. The artwork was the definitely gorgeous and the storyline has that “90s NBC Thursday sitcom vibes.” I was expecting XForce 1 to top the charts. I love the suspense and pacing of the story. Nice adrenaline rush. I’m very impressed with Fallen Angel charting top 10 higher than Marauders and Excalibur. Never thought Kwannon and her assassin past could be so intriguing. I look forward to her questionable dealings with Sinister. Hot mess in the making and I’m loving every single moment lol. Marauders have so much potential but the 1st issue felt lackluster. It felt like a Saturday morning cartoon. Emma was too comfortable in the top, It would have been dope to see Shaw make a power move from the get go. Kitty just looks irritable and miserable for the most part. She needs a better motivation to playing along with the hellfire club. She could definitely use a teleported in her team. (Paging Blink!!!) Excalibur was just disappointing all around. Pure blasphemy.

[Maestroneto]

As I said in the OP, New Mutants had an Artgerm variant.

Also, people still don’t know these are ordered months in advance?

[spirit2011]

Arent you being a bit over entusiastic about numbers 1?

A bit, but #1s are perfoming good. Not sure how the other launches performed.

Only x-men kept the top 10 from the 3 boks launche don september

As I said in the OP, New Mutants had an Artgerm variant.

Also, people still don’t know these are ordered months in advance?

Yep. no way Xavier dead would impact sales, if they are ordered months in advance

[pandafarmer]

The thing that shocks me most is that you'd think X-Force's word of mouth on the "shocking ending" would have driven more buyers. New Mutants is a great book, but I would assume it would have higher up front buys than a cliffhanger generator which brings people in over time.

[Hi-Fi]

Roberto da Costa is a superstar. Deal with it.

[Triniking1234]

Well Diamond's numbers are orders to stores. X-Force probably got 2nd printing requests after that ending.

[Digifiend]

Yeah. Things like Xavier getting killed will only affect sales of second and subsequent printings. We didn't know that was going to happen when these orders were put in.

[spirit2011]

Not to disagree, but X-Men #2 did do better than ASM. Yes, still too early, but still not a bad sign either.

Second issue. ASM is on 33-34 issue. big difference

The thing that shocks me most is that you'd think X-Force's word of mouth on the "shocking ending" would have driven more buyers. New Mutants is a great book, but I would assume it would have higher up front buys than a cliffhanger generator which brings people in over time.

And it drove, x-force got 2nd printings. But orders are placed 3 months in advance

[RD155]

Second issue. ASM is on 33-34 issue. big difference



And it drove, x-force got 2nd printings. But orders are placed 3 months in advance

Yep agreed. Add on top of that also that ASM has kind of hit a slump recently. It hasn’t been good at all. X-men even though the title is terrible right now, is still riding high from the HOX\POX Hickman hype.

[cranger]

Second issue. ASM is on 33-34 issue. big difference

Yep agreed. Add on top of that also that ASM has kind of hit a slump recently. It hasn’t been good at all. X-men even though the title is terrible right now, is still riding high from the HOX\POX Hickman hype.

Wow, it is almost like I did not say I agreed with the post I was replying to nor added for clarity that it was too early to celebrate.

[hulkling]

Not to disagree, but X-Men #2 did do better than ASM. Yes, still too early, but still not a bad sign either.

I think X-men 2 will be around 100k . X-men 1 was aroun 200k , that is the normal drop with numbers 1

[cranger]

I think X-men 2 will be around 100k . X-men 1 was aroun 200k , that is the normal drop with numbers 1

So if X-Men can settle into around 75K that would be pretty solid.