Exactly, this entire argument is "It's completely fine for this group of untrained and unregulated people to fight crime, but not this other group because they're under the legal drinking age". Any of the kids could join the military on their own (or with their parents permission) and be sent off to kill in a war but, fighting crime (non lethally at that) and suddenly they need some vague form of training and supervision. Besides the ones that have explicitly worked for SHIELD which of the adult heroes have had any actual training? I want to know what this training entails because whatever it is I highly doubt most heroes have had it taught to them. I can't understand anyone saying the kids need the supervision but the adults don't. And as others have mentioned compared to other superhero accidents this is about as tame as it gets no one even died which is very impressive considering a building collapsed.
Civil War - the teen version. Because Marvel will not let that thing die.
Hmm, I liked it enough and will admit being interested to see where things go to buy the rest of the story. No choice in the matter anyway since I read Ms. Marvel, but yeah it's hard not to see this as another Civil War event just without the name. No matter how they're gonna try to make some sort of dilemma or serious topic out of it, it sounds like in the end it will really boil down to...
I agree, it would be hypocritical to say that younger super heroes need regulation but adults don't. So, taking the idea to its logical conclusion, I beleive that Kamals's Law should apply to all super heroes. The honest truth is that Iron Man should've won Civil War and made the Registration Act a permanent part of the Marvel Universe. Perhaps then Marvel might've evolved a little, instead of retreading the same old ground and becoming increasingly out of touch with the modern world.
This looks awful and how do they know how old everyone is? Do they have to get a Superhero age card to carry around? It's just stupid. Looks almost as bad as the New Warriors which looks like the biggest turd Marvel may have ever released. How does C.B. let this junk even get out of the idea room?
Well the Marvel Universe did have those story sensibilities in The Initiative. So It is not out of realm of possibility for Marvel . MHA is putting on clinic Superhero genre and it isn't real hard for Marvel to transition to something similar they already but reverted because.....tradition in the real world and comic world they put Norman Osborn in charge of Shield..Sigh.
As for Outlawed it was pretty solid, I will wait to see escalate before judging it to harshly.
That's a valid point. But it's publicly known that Ms. Marvel is a teenager, and if it wasn't already known the younger Spider-Man was a teen, that fact was outed in recent issues of Miles's book - he's now known to be one of the students at Brooklyn Visions. Ironheart and Nadia don't have secret identities and have been running teen science groups.
Appreciation Thread Indexes
Marvel | Spider-Man | X-Men | NEW!! DC Comics | Batman | Superman | Wonder Woman
Iron Man did win civil war, and the SHRA did become a part of the Marvel universe for like 4 years.
The problem is that it was too easily exploitable and got taken over by Osborn.
All government intervention in marvel only exists to at best show them as incompetent and obstructive, or at worst fascist
The only positive logical conclusion of marvel would be to have a stateless society and volunteer heroes