I didn't really object to Winick writing her, just that he should not have tried to include her in a story at the 11th hour...in her solo. And if he did, her part in it should have concluded in her solo as well. But he did mostly get her personality; though I think some of his dialog was a bit clunky. Which can be a problem I admit. Getting a character's voice down is hard. I think Waid sort of did it in that Brave and the Bold with Wonder Woman...but it was the Power Girl of the past, not the more mature one we see in the JSA titles or her solo. That one has toned down the "fools rush in" bit of PG's personality...a bit. Just enough so that you don't think she doesn't belong leading the JSA. Simone got it close to right, but again, her PG is a bit too impulsive, as she was earlier in her career.

If any of them were to write her again, I would be okay with it. Especially if they have a plan to actually do something with her.