the only thing that puts reed's run above the others is that it had a consistent theme to it of carol trying to be a better hero and realizing she hasn't lived up to her potential.
Deconnick and Thompson somehow had less direction despite reed's run nhaving more crossover
It also tried to bring back her old villains like mystique, doomsday man, AIM (and created headcase from it), Brood.
There's no concept of where you want to go with it. It's not necessarily out of the box, it's just got more theme.
Deconnick lost her theme post mindwipe, Kelly Thompson doesn't seem to have any at all