Bill the Butcher vs Movie Joker

[Shai-Hulud]

Bill the Butcher (Gangs of New York) vs a composite of Nicholson, Ledger, Leto and Joaquin versions of Joker.

Movie Joker gets composite feats, but not stacked abilities (not x4 normal strength, etc).

Fighters get equivalent knives, no other weapons, items or gadgets.

Standard arena match.

[Shai-Hulud]

Where's Colonel GM?

I thought that he, at least, would respond to my thread.

Wait a minute, I got it. Forgot something.

ADDENDUM TO OP:

No BFR and No TP.
Who Wins?

That should do it.

Someone message the Colonel and get him over here please?

[Pendaran]

This thread is now best thread. It's just missing an attempt by you to get me to wield Stormbringer.

[Pendaran]

More seriously, feels like it's Bill's fight to lose, though granted I haven't seen any performances from Leto Joker, for all I know they made him some super skilled combatant for some terrible reason.

[Cantget]

Bill wins. The only Joker who brings anything to the fight is Ledger Joker, and I don't think he shows enough to beat Bill.

[The Drunkard Kid]

More seriously, feels like it's Bill's fight to lose, though granted I haven't seen any performances from Leto Joker, for all I know they made him some super skilled combatant for some terrible reason.

If you walk around looking like Jared Leto Joker, you probably get really good at keeping people from stabbing you.

[master of read]

haven't seen phoenix joker, so i can't judge on him.

but out of the others, ledger joker was the only one who mixed it up with batman.

there is a reason why they call bill "the butcher". dude was a highly skilled street fighter and knife thrower. if he doesn't land a blade between joker's eyes, he'll get up close and just start butchering.

[master of read]